Or the mad raving of a luddite. You decide!
Wave Ranch came fully online a little over 24 hours ago and I have been mired in bottomless depression since. I watched it, like you, from home. I watched blurry Instagram stories morph into giddy Stab boys peeking over the fence morph into an embarrassingly written World Surf League “live blog” morph into a very rich friend, who had been invited, texting me videos of Eddie Vedder changing Yellow Ledbetter lyrics to praise Kelly Slater’s creation. “Thank you Kelly for bringing us to this place…”
A slow motion accident.
A fucking nightmare.
And I realized that I hate Wave Ranch. I hate it with everything in me and with no pulled punch in vague hopes of getting invited to surf it one day. I hate it with a hatred reserved for drunks who speed through red lights near elementary schools and the Apple Genius Bar.
Hate.
Because it is officially over. The dream has died. Surfing has been successfully and cleanly amputated from “surfing.” The simple physical act from one of the most wonderful, most indescribable joys on earth.
You have, of course, read William Finnegan’s brilliant Barbarian Days. What I love most is the book’s pacing. Mr. Finnegan slowly meandering through his life and showing how surfing is tied to each strand of his DNA, inextricably woven, and even though he is very important as a real journalist for a real magazine when it came time to write his memoirs he wrote it about surfing. About A Surfing Life.
A surfing life.
Surfing has infected me, too, since the very first time I saw it playing out in cold Santa Cruz waters. And infected me all the way. It has dictated where I have lived, the cars I have bought, the women I have loved, the places I have gone. Seagulls, Lighthouse Beach, Bolsa Chic, Baja, Xanadu, Rockin’ Fig, JC, black sand, tar, smokey skies, burning sunsets, Soqotra, Lebanon, More Core Division, flat tires, warm beer, Mukalla, salt. It has been my adventure and my curse. The physical act of surfing is only part of the broader surfing life but the iteration that took place behind a fence in green fresh water underneath manure scented skies being watched by very rich potential investors was only about the physical act. Cleanly amputated. Genetically modified. Re-grafted.
Of the Instagram clips I watched on that fateful day, one summed up my feelings succinctly. Previous pool clips had been edited professionally and from either behind or straight ln. The surfer in the middle of the frame, the wave breaking behind and the shoulder running ahead. Except the shoulder isn’t running ahead, is it. The clip I watched featured Carissa Moore surfing fantastically and being chased by a jet-ski. Just feet behind her was that near perfect barrel that we’ve all marveled at. Just feet ahead of her was a giant wall. The mechanical guts of the oversized plow running underwater and creating the phantasm. A wall. The surfer surfs the entire wave facing this wall.
https://www.instagram.com/p/BZRGms2DNEq/?taken-by=mayhemb3_mattbiolos
When I close my eyes, amongst the best memories I conjure are dropping into a wave, looking down the line and seeing endless possibility. Seeing the gentle curve or the section far away that might pitch or the terror inducing double up. Seeing the unknown. Feeling the unknown.
Oh I know this reads like the mad raving of a luddite and maybe it is. Maybe I’m wrong. Maybe Wave Ranch and each next iteration is a glorious egalitarian utopia but I seriously doubt it. It feels more like the purposeful unraveling of a great mystery. Like man’s forever folly.
And here you can also listen to the mad raving of a luddite. I don’t ever recall ever approaching a surf topic with such deadpanned passion. Listen and tell me that I’m wrong. Tell me that this ain’t the end.
The new ones…keep up here…🤣
I reckon I have about the same chance of getting a good set wave at Snapper as I do of getting a wave at Kelly’s pool.
All the Canadian, Alaskan, Russian and Chinese points will be explored when L.A. drowns…..
I’m reminded of when Dylan picked up the electric guitar and the beatniks freaked out…..it’s all an illusion…
Hey Chas remember when you said.. “nostalgia is a rotten fruit”?
How do you explain yourself now?
That was my thought too. I wonder if Derek the man who is in the now is totally on board with the Ranch concept, leaving Chas surfing 2 ft windblown Georges! I will take the Ranch if the opportunity arises. That wave is sick!
too much hate in this article..
Since all the surfers on the WSL are part owners of the WSL, that makes them partial owners of the KS Wave Co. therefore the surfers were permitted to stream the event.
When v2.0 looks like this I’m sure we’ll all be much happier https://uploads.disquscdn.c…
Preach Chas, The emperor wears no clothes, don’t matter how you spin it.
An agressive marketing from Kamp Kelly… ops!… sorry!… from Wave Ranch!
From 0:00 to 0:37 the best merchandising from our Ranch to you!
Ihaaaaa John Boy, Mary Ann, Ben Jo Boy, Mary Jo, Jim-Bob, Liz Boy
Welcome!!!
https://www.youtube.com/wat…
ha ha this reads like about half of a piece I wrote yesterday for someone else
Would prefer to surf the Ocean, but fuck me if there is the opportunity to surf night time at a local wave pool because its been onshore, flat or have had to travel for work i’m all over it!!
you can learn to “surf” in a pool but you need ocean experience to be able surf real (large) waves well and survive. You can learn to “surf” in a pool bu that not going to help you out at big sunset.
In regards to my previous comments stating that the Wadi wave pool reigns supreme for its multiple wave styles(closer to real surfing), I stand corrected. These new sections Kelly has added make this more like surfing than skating one mini ramp over and over. Kelly, invite me!! I’ll do chop hops.
this all feels very rollerball to me.
When does this become more than just a novelty? How does this become economically viable? One thing that makes it harder is the playing field. All sports (I can think of at least) have static playing fields that, once they’re built, can be used repeatedly without need for heavy/costly maintenance (compared to driving a plow several hundred times over the course of an event). The field is not required to be “alive” to make the game work like wave pool surfing would. This has to be prohibitively costly…
I don’t think this portends the death of real surfing. The WSL? Probably. But that was happening anyway.
… lotta words up there.
P.S. Chas, you say “Vegas” funny.
once the novelty is over (18 months, absolute max) this thing is going to end up as some kind of therapy along the lines of SUP yoga for the Malibu set.
Exactly.
Dunno. I’ve just been confronted by small flaccid conditions which I chose not to flounder in. If I had the option I would happily vapourise $100 for 8-10 waves in Kellys pool.
Ha! How it supposed to be pronounced?
Haha I don’t know. My whole life I’ve heard it like vay-gus (like David pronounces). You say it like veh-gus. Just hit my ear weird (tickled).
Chas- weren’t two of BG commenters (in my memory one of them was even a BG writer) going to fight at Lennox Head? Update?
Longtom vs Webber – we are waiting still, but Webber is digging his pool to build up his core for said fight
Cable wake parks appear to be economically viable and somewhat related, no?
One of the things that truly struck me for the first time is, will the Ocean become more crowded, or less? With enough pools dispersed around the inland areas, Ricky Cane may truly become an issue in the line up. Families will start planning more vacations to the coast so Ricky can explore his true passion in the real arena. Yea he won’t have ocean knowledge, but, will know how to catch a wave and perform some proper turns? The others side of the coin is with that many pools, wiil this offset the present crowds?
Speaking as a developer of energy projects (pulling my dorky profession in here…) there is a big difference between building something one time, as a demonstration, and making it work financially/technically on a mass model. Seems lots of people see this wavepool and assume by next spring these perfect wavepools will spring up like battting cages all over the place. Not going to happen anytime soon, and I essentially don’t believe it every really will–too many fundamental challenges with the model IMO. So will this change surfing? No. Will this change competitive surfing? Yes, I think. So this affects all of us only to the extent you tie your surfing identity to what’s happening in the pro world. We all do, to some extent or another, but come on this isn’t ACTUALLY going to make a difference in our surfing lives
“It feels more like the purposeful unraveling of a great mystery.”
Unravelling yeah.
Purposeful nah.
It’s simple human endeavour – ‘we climbed it because it was there’ becomes ‘we built it because we could’. The only purpose being progress and ego.
nah, uber purposeful.
Slater sat down with engineers to design and make an artificial wave.
Same with Webber, same with Wavegarden.
This wasn’t some random byproduct of progress and ego.
The purpose was very much hardwired into it from the beginning.
But their purpose wasn’t to unravel a great mystery for all surfers – that was merely a byproduct.
Sigh, if (perfect) waves are the great mystery then sitting down and deliberately designing and then building perfect waves is “the purposeful unraveling of a great mystery”.
No?
I think Chas point holds up to scrutiny.
These weren’t a couple geeks tooling around with CAD who accidentally stumbled on a way to design and build a perfect wave “just because they could`’.
Well I read the point that it was Chas’ – and by extension every surfer’s – mystery that unravelled, you know that great romantic wondering that sates us (“Seeing the unknown. Feeling the unknown” as C.Smith says one paragraph hence), not a wave formula typed into a computer by a scientist….but fuck, I feel like an idiot explaining degrees of meaning in the subcutaneous zone of a comment thread.
exactly….I am trying to listen to the podcast now.
My wife overhearing: “fucking americans, can you just shut the fuck up”
I love Chas written rant above, made it 13 mins into the poddie.
All in all it’s just another brick in the wall
When do we get Greg Webber’s sizzling take?
I’m curious to see what this does for board design. I’d wager that boards designed for wave pools are gonna be quite different from traditional boards.
My question is how long before we see some chump with footstraps? Then it really becomes the bastard child we can reject with a clear conscience.
this is so easy to write-off with a clear conscience, you’re staring at a goddamn aquatrain the whole wave