South African surf mag publisher to Jamie
Brisick: “Bugger off New York shit talker!”
By Chas Smith
"A place where hope for humanity goes to die."
I’ve been lulled to complete sleep by the
Tahiti Pro Teahupoo presented by Hurley. When the waves go dumb
there’s not enough on the broadcast to keep a boy entertained. My
mind wanders here and there and then I feel bad for letting you
down too. For only posting “comment live” and “event wrap” back to
back to back to back.
No.
You deserve more than Strider Wasilewski duck-diving a wave with
microphone in hand while Joe Turpel says, “Epic conditions on a
historic day here at the end of the road.”
So here.
You certainly read Jamie Brisick’s New Yorker masterpiece from
a few days
ago wherein he discussed our new era where cameras are
ever-present and how they have created self-aware styles like the
one possessed by Mikey February.
A passage:
His hand jive, soul arches, and toreador-like flourishes
play to the camera in a way that breaks the spell of the itinerant
surfer in far-flung solitude. His style is as self-conscious as the
duck-face selfie.
Well, South Africa’s Zig Zag
magazine took offense to the slight. (Disclaimer: I
love Zig Zag magazine more than any American or Australian surf
pub.) Publisher Andy Davis headed straight to computer and wrote In
Defense of Aesthetics and MFEB’s Style and shall we sample?
Surf media hyenas and outrage specialist Beachgrit
immediately jumped on this passage and shared it under the
headline: THE NEW YORKER: “MIKEY FEBRUARY’S STYLE IS AS
SELF-CONSCIOUS AS THE DUCK-FACE SELFIE!” A brief scuffle ensued in
the comments section. A place where hope for humanity goes to
die.
(Disclaimer: being described as surf media hyenas and outrage
specialists gives me a unique thrill.)
And then…
Ultimately, Brisick has fallen into the trap, of judging
February by a feckless and imperial first world Californian surfing
standard, where being caught trying too hard is the ultimate sin.
It’s a curmudgeonly and spiteful comment, that fails to grasp a
broader global context and ends up saying more about his own
privilege than whether Mikey February’s style is
pretentious.
And all this to justify a perspective that itself rests in
the eye of the beholder and is as ephemeral as the mist on a
morning up the Wesksus. Here at the Zag, we say viva MFeb style,
voetsek New Yorker kakpraat!
Which, I was gracefully told, translates as “Bugger off New York
shit talker!”
So, is dear Jamie Brisick a feckless imperialist? Is Mikey
February’s style misunderstood? Are you where hope for humanity
goes to die?
Much to discuss and much better than current Teahupoo.
Eat it, Joe Turpel.
Loading comments...
Load Comments
0
Comment live: Finals day of the Tahiti Pro
Teahupoo presented by Hurley!
By Chas Smith
Come celebrate one last hurrah!
Yesterday, a hot full day of professional surf
action, was fun. There were controversies, upsets, fear, bravery
and the omnipresent Wall of Cotton Candy Sweet Positive Sound
coming from the World Surf League’s wood pallet wall’d booth. And
what do you imagine happens during World Surf League commentator
training, or rather what did happen those five years ago when Joey
Turpel and gang received their first new order training?
Did onetime World Surf League CEO Herr Paul Speaker say, “I
don’t care what you think you see, what you say
must be POSITIVE” or some equal directive?
I do not understand it and it feels insulting. It feels
profoundly insulting when Yago Dora sits for 35 minutes in non-stop
waves, catches one and Joey Turpel says, “Dora gets one and is
hustling back out to get back into the heat.”
But Dora was scared. He was not hustling to get back into the
heat. He wanted it over. Everyone could see it yet no one in the
booth could say it.
Infuriating and it makes me rage inside, shaking an impotent
fist at the screen, cursing both 1988 and 1989.
Well, Longtom wrapped yesterday’s hot
professional surf action almost too beautifully, and
please forgive my rude fist shaking, for yesterday’s hot action
also brought the return of the Li’l Plumber and the unveiling of
Caio Ibelli. Do either have a shot to win the 2019 overall crown?
Hope springs eternal.
And today is the last Teahupoo we’ll see all year before we head
inland to cow country. A gorgeous day before hell truly cometh.
Delaying the bottom turn for a micro-second
put Gabriel Medina as deep as humanly possible. The foam ball
pushed him around and almost threw him to disaster. He emerged and
splayed ten fingers out to the judges with a shrug. The only thing
unseemly about it was the time taken for judges to award a perfect
ten.
Tahiti Pro, Day 3: “Medina imperiously
calm; close to perfect; Kelly Slater too cute for judges!”
By Longtom
Six-to-ten-foot waves distended nostrils and
quickened hearts in the best contest day at Teahupoo in five
years…
Going to the land of nod last night knowing I/we would
be waking up to a day of eight-foot Teahupo’o broadcast
live made me feel quite deliriously excited.
I didn’t need to neck any sleeping pills like Filipe Toledo, but
then I wasn’t one who would be paddling out with the whole world
watching.
If the Tour disintegrated under the weight of its own
contradictions and all we were left with were a couple of
speciality events: Chopes, Pipe, maybe something in Indo it
wouldn’t be the worst outcome in the world.
Long as we got to watch it live.
Gotta say though, the draw did not excite as much. Lot of
one-sided encounters on there, some of which did run to script
while some turned out to be almost surreal in their reversals of
expected fortune.
Barton Lynch was enthusiastic to a fault in the post-show wrap
claiming despite the evil nature of the surf, “The world’s best
surfers had a dig” The missing qualifier “some of” was starkly
visible to all, except the commentary team.
Only the most timid observations of reality were allowed to
escape, if at all.
Overlapping heats seemed a disastrous choice for the day.
Confusion was the dominant theme, in the judging panel, in the
broadcast, amongst the watching fans. Too many waves were missed,
commentary had no clue what was going on, it was a mess.
Inconceivably, the WSL looked to have shot the one Golden Goose
that managed to fly into its orbit this year. I never thought I
would utter these words about pro surfing: there was too much
action.
Riding forwards on a longer board, Italo sat deeper than
Adriano, surfed on the foam ball and threaded multiple huge
carverns perfectly. I am sure one of his eight-point rides was
critically underscored. Maybe all of them.
Italo Ferreira and Adriano De Souza were the first to give the
day some shape and an epic flavour. I’m still deeply baffled by how
Italo lost.
Riding forwards on a longer board, Italo sat deeper, surfed on
the foam ball and threaded multiple huge carverns perfectly. I am
sure one of his eight-point rides was critically underscored.
Maybe all of them.
The final exchange was emblematic of the day: the second wave of
the set was the heat-winning wave and De Souza rode deep and long
on a …..what do we call it now in the Wavepool Era? Twenty-foot
wave?
It was a surreal close, commentators had brought in a babe to
discuss the coral gardening. Barton spent half the heat engaged in
WSL talking points while the best heat of the year played out in
front of him.
Barton’s worst day on tour as a commentator. He missed the other
high point of the day. Medina’s ten. More on that later.
De Souza could not be denied.
But even after rewatching I still can’t reconcile the Italo loss
after one of the most incredible performances ever seen at Chopes.
That he was beaten while another surfer in the concurrent
over-lapping heat barely caught a wave seems a criminal
travesty.
In round fucking three! Wasn’t the seeding round supposed to fix
this?
De Souza claimed a spiritual advisor in the departed Ricardo Dos
Santos accompanied him to his epic win.
His advice, according to De Souza,“You have to treat Teahupo’o
like you treat your wife” was wisely left uninterrogated by Rosie
Hodge in the presser.
Cardoso could not take off. Ricardo Cristie struggled. Wade
Carmichael was a deer in the headlights. Thirty-five minutes of a
heat passed without Yago Dora molesting a wave,or seducing it ala
De Souza. This caused the mellow Williams to declaim without a
trace of irony, “Some guys are a little better than the other
guys”.
Do not get me wrong. I do not judge.
CJ Hopgood in an impassioned commentary performance of mostly
unintelligible gibberish said when you surf Teahupoo the “the black
pearl is right behind you” and that you get to find out “what’s on
the other side of your fears.”
Real things, as it turns out. Shallow reef to be slammed into.
Death, serious injury. As a rec surfer who has looked down into the
belly of the beast as those west bowls bend at you and drain the
reef, it is the most frightening reality imaginable.
Brother had everything to overcome in his heat to hold the
yellow jersey. His own fear, the hometown crowd baying for his
seventeen-year-old Tahitian opponent, the waves themselves.
He did not let himself down.
He surfed a smart, brave heat. And then with a minute remaining
the broadcast inadvertently captured a moment of pure pathos. Vaast
paddled right past Andino and Andino’s expression of startled,
unknowing arrogance as he watched him segued perfectly into Vaast
stroking into a blue cement mixer which delivered a wild foam ball
victory ride for the wildcard. It was beautiful sport.
The yellow jersey now shifted to Filipe Toledo, if he could
somehow prove the naysayers wrong and make sense of full throated
Teahupo’o.
He did, barely, against Jesse Mendes. It was obvious he wanted
nothing to do with it. Christ, the man was coming down from
sleeping pills! You want to be up to surf Chopes, not down. He
could not force his way in there and wrangle a bomb.
With a heat almost spent Pip did get behind one and threaded it.
Judges were generous but as Pip paddled back to the boat the look
he gave Tatiana Weston-Webb clothed in a black Thrasher T-shirt was
not one of machismo, but more of sheepish acknowledgment that he
had done just enough to get the job done.
Ace Buchan in the booth spent the heat throwing shade at both
men. On Jesse Mendes he noted that Jesse was the defending Triple
Crown champion but was yet to really pack a bomb. He wryly observed
that Toledo “needs to be deeper”.
With a heat almost spent Pip did get behind one and threaded it.
Judges were generous but as Pip paddled back to the boat the look
he gave Tatiana Weston-Webb clothed in a black Thrasher T-shirt was
not one of machismo, but more of sheepish acknowledgment that he
had done just enough to get the job done.
In the presser, as he accepted the accolade of the yellow jersey
he said “I’m blessed” four times in one sentence. He did not look
like a man blessed. He looked shell shocked and half dead.
Jeremy Flores in a helmet was magnificent, but that is not
newsworthy. Same with his fellow helmutee Owen Wright. Both were
almost insanely competent and hungry for the bombs.
The surprise was Kelly Slater.
After watching all day the danger was Kelly would get too cute
and try and showboat his way to scores. Which he duly did, and
which judges duly lowballed.
The second wave of the set had been the heat winner. He took the
first. Jack Freestone was solid, just drew a clean line from A to B
under the axe.
Kelly needed one bomb to make the heat.
The set came.
Kelly, after spending most of his commentary session the other
day detailing how to make the drop, could not get in. He
pin-dropped from the top. And watched as Jack Freestone rode the
second wave to a heat-winning score.
Either wave successfully ridden would have been Kelly’s heat
winner.
After calling Kelly and Italo on day one it was a bitter pill to
swallow to see both gone while a third of the tour floundered like
toddlers in a wading pool.
It was pro surfing overload but somehow the Bourez/Owen Wright
heat cut through effortlessly. Owen rode a million deep tubes.
Bourez was crushed beneath a collapsing west wedge that was so, so
heavy.
On the ski ride back over dry reef into the lagoon he looked
like a floppy puppet.
He can’t come back from that, can he?
Minutes later he paddled into an even heavier one. A legit tow
wave. Impossibly heavy. He needed a high Nine. They gave him a
9.43. For a fucking tow wave! If there was ever a noble defeat this
was it.
Moniz and Ibelli were grand. They get short-changed here in the
hope tomorrow gives them the coverage they deserve.
The final word has to go to Medina. He was imperiously calm and
composed in dispatching Zeke Lau. Against a hard-charging Colapinto
in heat six of round four he was much much closer to perfect.
He rode two waves separated by more than 30 minutes.
The first to open: a deep, travelling tube, weaving in and
around the foam ball. A type of tube-riding he specialises in.
The second a much bigger throatier set. Delaying the bottom turn
for a micro-second put as deep as humanly possible. The foam ball
pushed him around and almost threw him to disaster. He emerged and
splayed ten fingers out to the judges with a shrug. The only thing
unseemly about it was the time taken for judges to award a perfect
ten.
And Barton missing it while an interview with Flores played on
the split. He missed it! The two peak moments of a day of days
missed by the booth, for shame.
A day where almost too much pro surfing was barely enough.
Thats a long wrap and so much has been left out.
Much to discuss etc.
Loading comments...
Load Comments
0
Comment Live: Day 3 (again) Tahiti Pro
Teahupoo presented by “Behold a pale horse and upon him sat
death!”
By Chas Smith
...and Hurley!
So tell me and tell me true, is today’s
Teahupoo forecast really going to be what World Surf League
President of Content, Media and Hyphy Rap Dancing Erik “ELo” Logan
calls “48 hours of #mustsee?” Is it going to be, as he also calls
“EPIC TAHITI?” The “monster swell of Kanoa Igarashi’s young
life?”
Oh he didn’t describe it as the monster swell of Kanoa
Igarashi’s young life but will it be?
Do you believe?
I was in the channel, on a boat during a medium-sized Teahupoo
swell once many years ago with Mikey Wright, Leo Fioravanti and
Kanoa Igarashi. Kanoa did not like it and refused to paddle. Oh, I
didn’t blame him. Seeing that beast up close is something that will
haunt me for the rest of my life. The reef is right there, like
right there, and the lagoon that folk gets washed into is
literally* filled with razor blades and MMA fighters pointy elbows
and the wave, that wave, is thick and fast.
Reflexes, man. You need reflexes.
Will any surfers chicken out? There are a full 32 of them. The
entire field minus four and one of those four is a young Tahitian
hell charger.
*Various dictionaries have officially changed “literally” to
“figuratively” to reflect usage.
The New Yorker: “Mikey February’s style is
as self-conscious as the duck-face selfie!”
By surf ads
Jamie Brisick observes "how the omnipresent camera
has affected surf style…"
There’s a scene in David Egger’s dystopian novel
The Circle where an
exec from a fictional Bay area tech giant is pitching a new
gadget to his adoring disciples.
It’s a Steve Jobs trope. Ear mic. Black skivvy. The whole
show.
But he’s also a surfer, and his breakthrough innovation is a
pocket-sized, mass- produced camera that can be placed on any beach
to live stream surf conditions. You can keep it as your personal
feed. Or you can hook it into the network of millions of others of
cameras
It’s the ultimate surf cam. Nowhere needs to be secret,
anymore.
Of course, like any good sci-fi, curly questions are posed about
omnipotent technology, the public’s right to know vs the
individual’s right to privacy etc
But the thing is, this sorta tech is already here.
The writer and former pro Jamie Brisick has written a story in
The New Yorker, and published today, riffing on this
very topic.
He opens his scene with a new VAL toy called Surfline
Sessions™. It’s an app that recognises
subscribers and records their every wave, if it’s in front of a
Surfline camera. You can have your videos cut and ready waiting for
you by the time you get back to your car to dry off.
The video guy for the everyman.
I saw another one recently that is a camera you leave recording
on the beach that follows you around the surf using a GPS
tracker.
Never miss a wave, anywhere, anytime.
On Mikey February: “His hand jive, soul arches, and
toreador-like flourishes play to the camera in a way that breaks
the spell of the itinerant surfer in far-flung solitude. His style
is as self-conscious as the duck-face selfie.”
It all makes for great marketing hooks. But isn’t also sorta
fucken …lame?
I quoted Parmenter recently when he said surfing is the ultimate
selfie sport.
In The New Yorker, Brisick takes it further.
On Mikey February:
“His hand jive, soul arches, and toreador-like flourishes play
to the camera in a way that breaks the spell of the itinerant
surfer in far-flung solitude. His style is as self-conscious as the
duck-face selfie.”
He then quotes Slater.
“Style should be natural, and not perfect. I really dislike
watching someone, anyone, who seems to be trying to look a certain
way.”
Is it true style when it’s just for the camera?
Even Al Knost’s biggest fan would say no. (Though I’ll still
watch him and Feb errrr’ damn day)
But what if constant recording can help you improve your
surfing?
Is it still narcissistic then?
Already, surf dads sit for hours on beach capturing their kid’s
every move for feedback. Surfing Australia do adult camps out of
their Cabarita high tower “for all levels of surfer”.
Even I did it recently with our Ments trip photog. It was the
first time I’ve seen proper video of myself surfing. It wasn’t
pretty.
But it did help me pick up on a few things I already felt I
might be doing wrong. I’m not about to go and hire Martin Dunn to
follow me around with a drone and a clipboard. But I will open my
shoulders a little more through top turns.
Surely that’s not a core crime?
Anyway, all argument is academic at this point. The future is
already here. In Egger’s Circle, the tech bro’s grand reveal is
that his cameras aren’t just capturing surfing. They’re also in
Gaza, and Chechnya, and inside politicians offices.
It’s full transparency, whether we like it or not.