Advertisement

Academic Paper proves Claims work: “Both laypeople and surf judges were biased by claims in judging surfing performances with claims (scoring) better than performances without claims!”

Science don't lie!

Some things in life sit beyond the tangible.

Not everything can be quantified. Nor should it be.

Why is the sky blue?

Why is water wet?

Advertisement

How does Chris Coté have such a hot wife?

Ageless questions that don’t always need an answer.

The Japanese have a word for the beauty inherent in these existential quandaries the world throws at us: yugen. There’s no direct English translation, but it’s best described as ‘an awareness of the universe that sits beyond words.’

The place beyond knowing.

Advertisement

As it relates to surfing, scientists shouldn’t be able to explain whether or not the sight of Tomas Hermes gesticulating wildly following a two foot close out re-entry will earn him the extra .1 needed to progress through to the non-elimination round.

They should be happy to just let it happen, with the reason for its effectiveness sitting someplace in the outerknown.

Yet, convinced claiming post-facto does matter and that they do influence judges, four German academics investigated “whether claims (postperformance nonverbal emotional expressions) influence people in evaluating performance during surf contests.

“To test this research question we sampled videos from professional surf contests and asked laypeople and surf judges to evaluate the performance in two online experiments.
A subset of the surfing performances showed surfers displaying post-performance emotional expressions (claims) whereas another subset showed the same performances without the claims (nonverbal celebration).”

Advertisement

It goes on.

“Both experiments provided evidence that both laypeople and surf judges were biased by claims in judging surfing performances with claims better than performances without claims. The findings are in line with social-cognitive models emphasizing the social consequences of emotion expressions. We discuss the implications of the findings for sport competitions that rely on judging sport performance.”

I’ll repeat that again, for effect.

Both experiments provided evidence that both laypeople and surf judges were biased by claims in judging surfing performances with claims better than performances without claims.

Advertisement

Illusions shattered! Claims do quantifiably work!

But what does this mean?

Now that their magic has been uncovered and the true effect of the claim has been documented with scientific rigour, should they be banned as an unfair advantage?

Filed under ‘unsportsmanlike conduct’?

Advertisement

Is this the death of the claim?

Slater famously called for donations to be made for any claim on a score lower than a nine, $1000 per point.

Would this be fairer?

Or should they be left alone as an endearing historical quirk?

Advertisement

Like spitting on the bride at Greek weddings, or befriending kneeboarders?

So much to unpack.

(Read paper here.)

0 0 votes
Article Rating

Commented on Disqus? Log out, tap the Disqus button, and your old name and comments come back. The box is ours.

Join the discussion

Your comments are still here. Every one of them.

Twelve years of BeachGrit comments came across from Disqus. Connect and we will show you how many are yours. We get your username, nothing else.

Unclaimed
Handle
Comments
Posting since

Connect Disqus to reveal.

Subscribe
Notify of
60 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Sean Callahan

Befriending Kneeboarders! Jajajaja!!!!

Chris Cote

What can I say, I have a great personality …

Kelly Slater’s Faith Healer

Having now read the study, and being someone with some statistical and experimental knowledge, I thought it was quite good.

It does however raise some questions: the first group consisted of people with no surfing experience (28%). It would be interesting to see how they dished out scores to the particular waves. This probably also gives explanation as to why the difference in claim vs no claim was less apparent than in the judges group.

The judges group had a larger range between claim and no claim, which is concerning for those on tour.

I think the most interesting aspect however, is that only around 30% realised they were watching repeat waves. I would have expected this to be much higher and subsequently flaw the study.

?uzzled

I liked the one from Mason Ho that accidentally looked like he was jerking off and he got in trouble for it.

James Bickerton

Having lived in a few different surfing cultures , I can truthfully confirm , that the only people who don’t claim on a regular basis outside competition , even the shittiest of rides , are English speakers from Hawaii , the USA , NZ , SA and Oz ….? Of course their are exceptions like Kai Otten .

@surfads

I claimed a barrel / sand aenema I got on a lid at Shelley beach wedge, Blueys, on New Year’s Day. Sorry, had to tell someone.

James Bickerton

The cathartic effects of confession …. go in peace to love and surf like a lord … standing up ..giggles

Mild mannered civil servant

Knee boarders are a very rare breed and need our help.

@surfads

Nothing but love

Mild mannered civil servant

Dysfunctional looking but strangely functional once moving and just strange humans in general. Seem to be extremely bold when in small groups (an extremely rare sight) where they’ll shutdown the lineup to all but their fellow kneelo.

Toin coss

A bad claim* can have a detrimental effect with judges, fans and sponsors resulting in all sorts negative repercussions.
Kelly had an acceptable claim after his 10 at backdoor. We all know why it was acceptable.
There’s so much riding on these heats, it’s realistic to see emotions leak out, anyone who can’t grasp that notion or think these people shouldn’t express emotion are out of touch.
Forced claims are weak, authentic claims capture the human condition.

Greg Shark

Befriending knee boarders should be met with utter disdain….

OffRocker

I dunno, it’s kinda like that weird kooky but interesting kid from your street who you hang with at home, but won’t talk to at school…. they turn out to be mass murderers or millionaires. Either way, worth knowing…

Return of the Samsung Board

Man she is hot. Damn

Doobalachy

So who else clicked on the cc wife link?

Chief Hot stuff

No I clicked on the zero gravity sex link
Silvia was a Saint!! !

UniversallyAdoredDolphin

Whistle {spout}
Click click
Thphthphthp
Eeeeeeerreeerrrrr ck ck ck

Greebnurt Hurkurmurgurt

Rapey cunt. Keep your slimy bottle nose away from Coté’s wife’s clam.

Corey Webster

Claiming makes the world go round. Isn’t that the essence of social media, claiming this and that. You claim, they like. Have you ever had a job with a claimer who hardly did anything but claimed everything and management thought he was great? Just claim it was the biggest inauguration ever and half the nation will probably have your back, how bold of you. People believe a good claimer. That hack in 2ft slop really was amazing, I could tell it was from your claim.

Chief Hot stuff

It happens in every other sport.
It’s just that surfers are too cool for surf school
Fistpump!!!

channelbottom

There ya go.
Fisting yourself in public again.

Chief Hot stuff

They’re used to it.

rwvbwl

And still,
not 1 woman judgin’…
Why not???

https://uploads.disquscdn.c… https://uploads.disquscdn.c…

Low wide stinkbug stance

Who was the first woman on the moon?

James Bickerton

Luna Landing …. ?

Sandy  Johnson

Because it is a man’s world in the judging booth. They still pee in bottles up there, they check out women on the beach and discuss, etc…

pubes

Cote’s missus is hotter than sunburn. If only she didn’t think it’s a 540…

channelbottom

I don’t really dig chicks with Adam’s apples.

https://uploads.disquscdn.c…

Chris Cote

I used to be really good at partying.

Audit In Progress

So did Andy.

nyc surfing golden boy

is that erick logan?

channelbottom

Should we start claiming for every featured comment, potential featured comment or perhaps any comment whatsoever in the hope we will gain more up-votes?

Huli Opu

Like all surf claims, upvoting and featured comments on BG should be banned. Only soul arch exits allowed

channelbottom

Hey, I get $50 for every featured comment win and my sponsors will not be pleased if you attempt to change the competition format.

Huli Opu

you forgot to downvote me

channelbottom

I don’t pull people’s leashes, man.

Huli Opu

easy killer. I’m just playin’ wit you

channelbottom

I’m a lover, not a fighter.
I spread aloha, not anthrax.

Huli Opu

take a break CB. You’ve been going too hard lately

channelbottom

Bored bored bored bored bored bored bored bored.

Sorry. I’ll dial it back.
This is pretty much my only
outlet these days.

NEGATRON

I could ban you for couple of weeks if you want to try and integrate yourself back into society?

channelbottom

Sure!
Why not.

May I be the first to claim a voluntary ban-hammer, please.

Won’t reintegrate me into society as I ain’t got none.

Bye!

(Holds 10 fingers up to judges)

NEGATRON

You gotta promise to take your Wife out for dinner or file for divorce though.

?uzzled

I think that your claims are almost as good as the penis fish picture.

Chad Lebrone

“I don’t wannt be a part of this dumb fucking wannabe tennis website anyway”

James Bickerton

In the 80s there was the sponsored surfer PHOTO SLUT who dropped in on everyone in the hope that catching more waves would increase his chance of being photographed which might increase the chance of him having a photo printed in a surf magazine which having a photo incentive clause in his contract meant that some one like Hot Tuna or Mango would give him a certain sum depending on the size of the photo , which mag it was in and where it appeared in the magazine eg Cover of American Surfer = BINGO !

All that just to ask you CB what name would you like to give yourself to replace Photo Slut ?

Instalo Feedeira

It doesn’t work trust me.

Nick Carroll

ha ha ha ha ha just think someone paid for that research.

channelbottom

Likely not Bluestar.

Nick Carroll

Bluestar won’t pay for the steam off surfing’s piss. 3/4 of Hurley’s staff will be gone before the end of January. I would reckon every single surfer on that team had best not expect to be given the courtesy of a walk through to the end of their contract.

Time’s up gang. Better follow Kanoa and Gabriel etc into non endemic land, or learn to live off prize money.

channelbottom

‘Course not. Hence my snarky comment.

(Hands up towards judges)

?uzzled

I upvoted for the claim.

Yesterday's hero

Or follow you into surf journalism?

astro

That is our future … surfings fucked.
mainstream commodification is very nearly at critical mass and going to squash us.
4 germans researching surfing – faaaarrrrkkk.
Nick, milk the cow while you still can. Aussies and kiwis will soon be lectured to by euro cunts …. instead of Cali cunts.
It’s fucked.

Nick Carroll

ha ha astro surfing’s in the doing, not the researching.

I’ll be 80 years old before any of those idiots can paddle up my inside.

astro

Hahahahar
Ok, boomer !

OffRocker

Boardporn IG just posted a 5 foot something twin fish, made for Kim kardashian. We are indeed fucked Astro.
https://www.instagram.com/p…

Numbnuts

Seems like a 9 foot longboard with black rails kinda girl…

Kelly Slater’s Faith Healer

Trust the Germans to try and understand surfing. The four probably needed to fund another trip to a crowded line up on the east coast.

DrunkenAngel

glass houses and stones, etc.


60
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x