Essential.
Surf media is falling all over itself to heap the most superlative praise on Apple+ Television’s just released series Make or Break though is it all deserved or another example, in continuous string, of our kind just gagging to be noticed? I’ll be extremely honest with you. I was worried it was the later after watching episode one. Tyler Wright’s narrative felt canned and the lack of genuine stakes seemed ridiculous what with non-stop hyperbole gushing from interviewed mouths.
Wayne “Rabbit” Bartholomew, I think, said of last year’s tour, the one being filmed, “This is the greatest assemblage of talent in the history of the sport.”
Um, no.
Also, “Any of these guys could beat anyone.”
Also no.
11x champion Kelly Slater, speaking of Pipeline’s deadliness, declared, “It’s super dangerous. Somebody dislocated their shoulder this morning.”
As a chronic dislocater, not dangerous or deadly.
Etc. Etc. Etc. and I was concerned heading into episode two, The Brazilian Storm, especially when it began “Filipe Toledo is the most dangerous competitor on the world tour.
? unless “dangerous” and “dislocated shoulder” are now synonymous.
But then magic begins to unspool albeit slowly. The cameras focus on Gabriel Medina and his then wife Yasmin Brunet early. Medina having split from step-father Charlie and mother in order to make his own way with archival footage and tears. It flips to Italo Ferreira and his childhood friend and traveling partner who makes him smoothies and also admits to not being appreciated. Andy King is unveiled as Medina’s new coach, more tears flow, Medina and Ferreira go back and forth winning and losing events on the Australian leg, Filipe Toledo, the aforementioned “most dangerous” pops in and out and scene.
The subtle insights are fascinating but the real glory, for us honest-to-goodness professional surf watchers, is this bizarre time capsule. We know that Medina divorced Brunet and quit the tour for a mental break, for example, and to observe him shooting daggers through her when she tells him to “surf for fun,” when she says, “People think I am going to derail his career” are pure gold.
Kafka could not have written it better.
And so the only complaint I was left with was a lack of insight from us honest-to-goodness professional surf watchers. The camera follows Ferreira, for example, into a live Ain’t That Swell show and my gracious if that doesn’t look wildly fun but neither Jed Smith nor Vaughn Blakey are interviewed. Instead, Stace Galbraith and Luke Kennedy are utilized in the “surf journalist” role. Now, I’m sure both are wonderful but neither are vicious and we (read: you) are vicious.
That bit is missing, honest-to-goodness analysis, criticism, hot-takes from The People™. It appears, through the episode, that “surf fans” are pure, spooning down the storylines churned out by our World Surf League, which seems a miss.
A small complaint, though, especially when episode two flips to episode three and Jay “Bottle” Thompson reveals the origins of his nickname.
David Lee Scales and I, anyhow, discuss over the best fusion tacos and burritos I have ever had in my life. From New Jersey, it should go without saying.
Essential.
Commented on Disqus? Log out, tap the Disqus button, and your old name and comments come back. The box is ours.
Your comments are still here. Every one of them.
Twelve years of BeachGrit comments came across from Disqus. Connect and we will show you how many are yours. We get your username, nothing else.
Connect Disqus to reveal.
Word
Jen there is alot to talk about here would love to hear what you think when u get a chance to see it
Less basic below the belt bloke talk down here would help.
When you said love triangle I thought it was going to include that soccer guy.
Negs, make it happen.
Spoiler alert-
Next episode is a replay of Tyler’s 30 minute deranged speech at surfers poll awards.
Jen?
Cmon. Forget this shit. What about the Zeke and Jacob pre comp flick off comp, where Zeke won and lost all in the same move…..?
Just saw the clip…waiting on some details. Anyone?
I just saw it too. Looks like they were having great fun sharing a wave then someone took a hump and kicked his board towards the other’s head.
This is why we can’t have nice things.
Is there any new mind blowing surfing involved or is it just all about pro surfers and there tough luck, sad life’s stories?
Why? Chas and DR can’t be working through daddy issues and thus created BG as mechanism of so doing? Negs is prob working through them, by acting like all ours dad. Chazz probably would gamble on his being unsolvable.
Jen you have to see the trees for the forest. And then see the forest for the trees. And don’t see, Jen, any of the episodes.
(Content unavailable)
What did the comment say?
Hello Chas, in no disrespect, can’t you write something more artistic and long than mere live-letter tease texts to your fans? Write something longer and more substantial like Jen See does about this topic or whatever you put your writerly sites on??? Respectfully, Johnny Rotten Backsideslash
I meant to say “love-letter”!
only real review I could find of the series online, kinda nails it:
https://www.cultofmac.com/7…
You saying Chas’ article wasn’t a real review?
Heavy!
That’s a good read, thanks. It makes some good (important) points about being a non-surfer watching the show and the assumptions the show makes about background knowledge.
Insomnia + Adderall + vacation
I’m not gonna watch but want to know… care to spoil why the mental break?
SPOILERS
.
.
.
.
He said he was a victim of parental alienation. He explained he finally got to know his biological father last year which obviously did not sit well with his parents. He said that his mom and Charlie lied to him about his dad his entire life to keep them apart. Gabe said he found out a lot of what he was told was untrue.
He was pretty much bawling at this point. His last line on the show was him saying that now he needed to go spend some time with his biological dad
Thanks Dovakin! Sorry Gabe!
Sounds like Elo has combined dr Phil with the big O.
I bet he throws some jerry springer into the mix soon!
Tatti/Sage Erickson Sage Lets Tatti have it after a heat with a rash of F Bombs Tatti’s retorts she’s just playing the game
SPOILER ALERT……
……
…….
Yasmin Brunet” If he wins it means Im not ruining his Life or his career its really important for him its really important for me,Its really important for us and He Knows That.” Yeah it was heavy to say the least so for him to take time off I got no issue
The stuff with Felipe and what he goes thru was heavy watching Jack Robinson trying to brush off his Dad when they were walking back to their cars was on that level as well… Jack Robbo’s dad in that 20-30 secs seems so wheels off…
ITALO is a douchebag I’m sorry but if u watch this u will know what i’m talking bout from his breakfast IG routine to him watching Gabe Practice
Brah, I felt so bad for Robbo. That shit ain’t easy. I had similar issues with my dad (obviously a much smaller scale) and that shit is tough.
About Italo, lets start with the fact that he travels with a grown ass man who does his dishes and cleans up after him… I HAVE BEEN TELLING YOU GUYS for 2 years now! LOL he is a total asshole.
SPOILER ALERT……
The stuff with Italo and the Brazos is so telling they all hang together Silva Miggy Felipe Gabe outside of the contest area whether they are free surfing or playing cards or chilling at Felipe’s with his family EVERYONE ACCEPT ITALO … They ask Italo’s bitch boy cause thats what he is if Italo appreciates him and He said NO that was so epic but after saying No he said he gets to travel the world, PRICELESS…. make me breakfast film my clips do my laundry and on my off day I will take you down to the beach and we can watch Gabe Practice and we will make fun of him… The WSL tries so HARD to paint these guys as good vs Evil Gabe the evil one the Dark Knight and Italo Happy go Lucky & fun loving but his vibe is he is a dick
Honestly, I understand he is not a very charismatic person, but his competitive aggressiveness and the walls he put up come mostly from Charlie’s teachings. Charlie has always taught Gabe the entire world was against him. In his movie you can see this very clearly. Last year in Newcastle, when Gabe mentioned that he just wanted to surf from now on and not think too much about strategies, kind of confirmed that.
Italo used to be a nice guy until he started winning comps and getting lots of attention from gringos.
I felt for Robbo, too. That scene in the carpark. Oof. The pained look on Jack’s face as he tries to set an adult boundary with his unstable, narcissistic father. Then Morais just starts checking his phone when Trev’s crazy ass invades his space. Sooo awkward. Also, Italo. Wtf? Has he always been such a knob? I swear he used to be nice!
Travis Robbo is like a secular version of Gabe’s mom.
Jack, Gabe and Kanoa’s situation are actually very similar in terms of controlling parents not having any boundaries and pretty much living through their kids. Interesting to see how they all turned out so differently in totally distinct cultures.
That scene had a if an innocent bystander is in the parking lot please call child services vibe … DisturbingAF
Pops
I’ll listen and watch later
In episode 7 you’ll find out why he took a mental break. It ain’t her.
Her outfits ?
HYPER BOWL.
-Ronnie
And, every single one of the contest announcers say “verse” instead of “versus.” I seethe.
“Really unique”