Someone gonna die on a Byron Bay-Ballina beach in January, says shark fisherman…
The debate about shark fishing is the oddest thing I’ve ever encountered. We mow through every living creature that has even a modicum of texture and taste in its flesh, broiled, baked, served raw on deliciously fragrant rice, but when it comes to icing a few sharks we lose our shit.
We’re in their environment, surf at your risk, etc.
To suggest a few nets are thrown up a couple of hundred metres offshore to let the human animal swim unmolested invites ridicule and the sort of venom that has become the characteristic of the rigid left-wing mind (Just ask ’em about that Great Satan, America).
South Africa, South Australian, northern California? Yeah, sharks, we know. I keep a ledger in my head of shark attacks and keep it vigorously updated. With each new Great White attack, I lick the nib and carefully draw an imaginary pencil line through the area.
But when Australia’s north-east coast, home to Bulls and Tigers, sure, but never Whites, suddenly became insanely packed with ’em, attacks happening every other month, you’d would think, logically, maybe the government could string up a few nets?
That isn’t going to happen, of course, at least not without a few years of hand-wringing and a few more deaths.
Anyway, this morning, The Australian newspaper’s Fred Pawle interviewed a Ballina shark fisherman. It makes for instructive reading.
Let’s examine.
“If anyone in Ballina knows sharks, it’s David Woods. A commercial fisherman, he says he caught an average of 3.8 4m-long sharks every working day for 15 years. Now, having seen a spate of people killed or mauled by sharks around the northern NSW town, he says another fatal attack is imminent.
“Mr Woods stopped fishing for sharks in 2009 because restrictions on catches and the paperwork involved made his business unviable. Other shark fishermen in the area have done the same.
‘I’m predicting there will be another fatal attack in January,’ he said.
“He said this was traditionally the month when large great whites migrated back down the coast. This, combined with the constant presence of juvenile great whites, tigers, bulls and bronze whalers had made the water unsafe. Asked what percentage of his catch of large sharks were species that attacked people, he said: “They all were.”
“A Department of Primary Industries spokeswoman dismissed any link between the decrease in shark fishing and the increase in attacks.
There is no evidence that a decrease in the commercial catch of sharks has resulted in the increased number of recent shark attacks,’ she said.
“The NSW government has faced criticism over its apparent sluggish response to protecting ocean-goers, including the possible installation of shark nets on the north coast.
“Mr Woods bought his boat, designed to catch large sharks, in 2001 for $180,000. He targeted tiger and bull sharks and sold almost the whole body to various businesses: the meat went to fish fertiliser, fins were exported to China, liver and oil went to a Tasmanian smallgoods producer and the skin went to a South Australian tannery.
“At his peak, Mr Woods said, he was earning $250,000 to $300,000 a year., but he stopped fishing sharks in 2009 when the department introduced limits of 500kg a week. Now he is earning $80,000.”
“Another Ballina commercial fisherman, Paul Porter, said the worst time of year was January to March. Last year, while fishing for mackerel, often only 600m from where people were swimming, he was losing 20-30 fish a day to great whites stalking his boat. ‘The year before you’d lose maybe one a week,” he said. He estimated he lost $10,000 to $20,000 worth of fish to sharks in the three-month period.'”
What’s it like to have your head inside a living Great White? Click here!
And what’s it like to see your pal be swooped on by a White? Click here?
How fucked in the head is the government. There is no evidence a decrease in commercial catch of sharks has resulted in the increased number of shark attacks. Really?? seems pretty simple evidence. Not catchin em people are getting attacked that is the evidence. Why don’t they just say we don’t have a clue and none of us could really be fucked finding out why.
lennox point has been a mess, very poor work by the government for not coming up with a solution sooner, well into christmas holidays and nothing done yet! surf industry is falling apart here
good?
no you swine
Tiger sharks are incredibly abundant off QLD and N.NSW, particularly when we get that first flush of warm water from the EAC…….it’s a mystery why they don;t figure in more attacks like Hawaii and Brazil.
Studies have shown GWS to be very curious animals…..more than likely they come and check us out, the sight of dangling limbs or silhouette triggers a predatory response and bang.
I think the environmental hand-wringing comes from the estimated 50+ million sharks killed per year, mostly just for their fins. To think you can remove a top-level predator at that rate and not seriously fuck the ecosystem is crazy. I agree we do plenty to screw up the oceans already but does that make it a good idea to keep going in that direction?
Humans are horrible at evaluating risk, eating shitty food, drinking too much, car accidents, all dangerous things probably still more likely to kill you than a shark, but what gets all the attention?
That said, it sounds like a pretty terrible situation over in that part of Oz. Hope something changes and you guys can surf safely again.
Easy to conflate apples and oranges here.
The fact that millions of mostly oceanic sharks are being killed doesn’t change the fact that in Aus the mostly inshore GWS food supply is increasing, it is protected and commercial fishing effort generally is declining.
That means perfect storm conditions for increasing populations of GWS and lots of food inshore for them to feed on and hold them in inshore areas.
Just as an example; there used to be 37 trawlers working out of Ballina, that’s 37 boats hoovering up all kinds of fish and prawns. There’s now 5/6 and that is expected to reduce further to 3.
That means a whole heap more food at the bottom of the food chain which is available for predators in the ecosystem.
So yes, while it’s true that (oceanic) commercial overfishing is a huge global problem here in Aus we are seeing a reduction in commercial fishing effort and a big rebound in inshore marine biomass.
Now, what to do about it is the question. There’s people in the community who’d rather sacrifice their first born than see a hair on the head harmed on a GWS. Thats a fact.
This sounds a lot like utter bullshit to me – “says he caught an average of 3.8 4m-long sharks every working day for 15 years”
…that point-eight of a shark must’ve been a peculiar animal…
More than likely he spoke in feet and Fred changed to metric.
Killjoy!
Dunno how that’d work seeing as he was talking about the amount of sharks caught. Would’ve said he caught 1250 sharks a year, 330 working days, 3.8 average.
This morning I went to one of Ballina’s best surf spots, a spot I’ve surfed and loved for decades, a spot I haven’t surfed since Tadashi got his legs bit off in Feb. Gorgeous day, clear water, beautiful little waves.
No-one around, save a few pro fisherman waiting for bait schools.
“Mad to go out there by yourself”, was what one said to me.
I hung in the carpark , someone showed up eventually.
We both ummed and ahhhed, there were dolphins, bait balls, dark shapes in the water.
We both went out. Shark chopper flew low, circled us a couple of times, then headed down to Evans and came back, circled us again.
Fuck this noise, I thought and came in. Surfing around here has become a very weird mental trip.
Why is mega-scale commercial fishing for large pelagic fish being left out of the argument? The local fishos take fuck all compared to the massive, foreign production ships roaming further out.
So heavy! Im from a fairly sharky place and when I used to go to Ballina I thought it was paradise!. thought nothing of paddling to south wall across the river.. that would surely be suicide these days. Damn shame. I say get David Woods and Paul Porter backout there and knock a few over