Poll: Surfing’s most principled stand?

It takes guts to stand, or sit, for what you believe in! But who is surfing's most conscientious soul?

Football season kicks off in America today which means summer is officially over. Goodbye beached days and mai tai nights. So long lazy afternoons and slow mornings. Arrivederci sun tans and sun block.

Hello Colin Kaepernick!

Lat-sp-colin-kaepernick-anthem-wre0041208767-20160901

And have you kept up on the San Francisco 49ers’ quarterback? He has set the country on fire by refusing to stand for the national anthem! He says he will not stand until there is some improvement in race relations:

I am not going to stand up to show pride in a flag for a country that oppresses black people and people of color. To me, this is bigger than football and it would be selfish on my part to look the other way. There are bodies in the street and people getting paid leave and getting away with murder.

It sounds reasonable, no? Well, I was among the thugs in San Diego watching my most favorite Chargers a few days ago and the boos raining down upon Colin’s head were thunderous as he took his knee. He was called all sorts of nasty names with many “Fuck yous!” being thrown in for good measure.

Like it or not, approve or not, it takes guts to make a principled stand.

Which made me wonder… What was the biggest principled stand ever taken in our surf world?

Was it Bobby Martinez saying what he really thought about the professional surf tour?

Bobby Martinez Interview

Was it Mick Fanning refusing to refusing to speak with a certain surf reporter, before speaking to him, because he understood he worked for a magazine and that it had previously published articles which he believed were racist and anti-Semitic? By the way, he strongly objected to views, statements and comments of that nature…

Was it Dane Reynolds not surfing in contests and not making videos at the same exact time while getting paid lots of money?

Was it…

…Matt Warshaw? Are you there again? I need you!

0 0 votes
Article Rating

Commented on Disqus? Log out, tap the Disqus button, and your old name and comments come back. The box is ours.

Join the discussion

Your comments are still here. Every one of them.

Twelve years of BeachGrit comments came across from Disqus. Connect and we will show you how many are yours. We get your username, nothing else.

Unclaimed
Handle
Comments
Posting since

Connect Disqus to reveal.

Subscribe
Notify of
33 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
NEGATRON

You read Chas’s Andy story? It’s honest but not as brutal.

Preston

Well, while we are the subject of Mr. Horan, his insistence to ride experimental equipment surely cost him at least 1 world title.
The boy was principled if nothing else.

Mapski

Surfing’s most principled stand? The inclusion of Matt Warshaw in Surfer Magazines “New Hot 100” issue(Oct.82). Bold.

Brutus

yeah Tom’s was a very principled stand , how about dane Kealoha , refused the ASP/Kanga directive that Hawaiians could not surf the Tripple crown , lost all his points and was told he would have to requalify thru the Qualifying series..ended his career , and still Kanga can’t go to Hawaii!!

Mapski

Dane should have been crowned champion that year. Atrocity.

Brutus

yeah he took a stand to surf in his home event , knowing it would probably cost him his career , as he had already been ripped of in the semi-finals the year before when all he had to do was get thru the semi to world champ , 2 judges had him first , 3 lightning Bolt judges had him last , MR went onto win !

Mapski

The headband photo of him by Warren Bolster is religion.

Nick Dee

The video again of Bobby Martinez being a dickhead; showing ingratitude to the hand that fed him. That was a good comp in New York, Slater doing airs & Owen winning. Life rolls/rolled on Bobby. Medina came on tour, surfed to his potential, the rest is history.

Owen Ravenscroft

I thought Dave Parmenter’s last hurrah was pretty special.

Matt Warshaw

Pearls before swine.

Abscessed Llama

Reaching imagery contrasting Todd Klein’s bite lip smirk, to 1968 Olympic Games silent solute protest. Might as well compare Lewis Samuel’s black eye to Rodney King beat down..

20 mule team

Sarge standing up against the tyranny of heterosexuality and consent.

Doognog

Sarge has been thrown around this website quite regularly over last two weeks. Any chance BG could do a little history piece on this once heralded photographer or are somethings just too taboo?

NEGATRON

Have you read this fantastic piece? http://stabmag.com/style/sa…

Doognog

Cheers!

NEGATRON

This one too… http://beachgrit.com/2016/0…

Doognog

Wow that was some serious breakfast reading!

Matt Warshaw

Tom Carroll refusing to surf 1985 ASP comps in South Africa. Potts, Curren, Cheyne, others joined in later, but at first it was Tom all alone. He was defending world champ, and not going to Africa may have cost him another title. Brave crazy little man did it on a whim, but it was very much the right thing to do, and we lefty surf press members (there were a few, Holmes and Jarratt among them) were thrilled beyond belief.

Nick Dee

Did Horan boycott South Africa? I don’t recall he did. The ASP Archive shows his name in every Gunston 500 up to 1993, except 1985 & 1989, the later he probably could afford to go (earning US$17K for 1988) since he had not won a heat there in years. After pocketing US$50,000 at Sunset in 1989 & US$78K for 1989, the 2nd highest earnings after Pottz, he was back in South Africa in 1990. Apartheid ended in 1994………..”Cheyne Horan felt he could not afford to lose points in building his career or his sponsorship money, so he made the decision to protest in a different way. He decided to go to South Africa and ride a board with FREE MANDELA painted on it, knowing Nelson Mandela was Public Enemy No 1 in South Africa, and was in prison serving the twenty-first year of what would be twenty-seven years. Riding the Free Mandela board in South Africa made Horan the target of bullying by officials, strident criticism from surfers, harassment and eventually death threats.” (quote from internet)

Matt Warshaw

Boycotted for sure in ’86, and I think he ’86 he went back with “Free Mandela” airbrushed on his board. Like this, altough not sure if this is in South Africa.

Nick Dee

Thanks. As I posted, the ASP Archive shows Cheyne was not there in 1985 so maybe he did join Tom from Tom’s 1st boycott in 1985. Here: http://archive.aspworldtour…

Nick Dee

NC will go for my throat but wasn’t Tom needing to wriggle out of the contract with Shaun Tomson’s Instinct Clothing brand so he could re-sign with Quik? I recall reading TC’s bio years ago and when he was with Instinct & surfing freezing cold J-Bay with Shaun, Tom didn’t even have a decent wetsuit, his wetty having holes & tears. …….”As it happened Carroll wasn’t forced to surf in South Africa but he did lose his main sponsor, Instinct Clothing. Instinct were a US and South African-based company who had South African pro Shaun Tomson as their main rider and the decision riled. Within weeks Carroll’s manager Peter Manstead negotiated a contract with Quiksilver that, at one stage, made him the world’s highest paid surfer. It’s a relationship that continues to this day.” (quote from Swellnet)

Matt Warshaw

In both of Tom’s bios it comes off as a humanitarian stand all the way. Shot from the hip, total suprise to both Nick and manager Peter Manstead, but still from the heart. I think with a world title up for grabs Tom would have found another way out of his Instinct deal, if that was a problem.

Nick Carroll

No need to throat-go Nick. I don’t think it crossed Tom’s mind for a moment that his contract with Instinct would be a casualty of his decision. (He did totally know what it would cost him in terms of a shot at another world title.) He is a funny little bloke, not very worldly by nature, but with a very tough resistant core of right-and-wrong that he got from our Mum and Dad via osmosis. (Our Mum was a staunch left-winger and very alive to issues of race, and Dad has made one or two similar decisions in his life, one being not to work for Rupert Murdoch. But I digress.) He also took the role and responsibility of world champion very seriously; the world champion roll-call to us at the time felt not just like a sporting achievement but a position in which you were placed almost by Fate, where you could choose to do important stuff on behalf of the surfing world, or fail to do so and somehow fail the sport as a result. There was also a bigger context about which many Americans, for instance, might not have been aware at the time; many sporting teams from Commonwealth countries were engaging in a boycott of South Africa in the hope it would swing the politics of the nation against apartheid. Given all that, Tom’s decision might seem a bit easier to understand, but it did not save him from a lot of significant nastiness in various quarters of the surfing world, including from many of his fellow pros, and from many in the South African surfing community, who did their best to spread rumours about Tom’s motives. The fact is that Instinct dropped Tom almost immediately after his announcement — their choice, not his — and he was pretty lucky to have Manstead around to pick up the pieces via Quiksilver, who had dropped Tom three years beforehand in a bid to throw all their resources behind Rabbit for a world title, and who had since been rueing their decision. To me, my little brother’s decision stands as the only time in surfing history when a champion has stood up and made a call on a serious moral issue to his potential detriment, without any concern other than doing the right thing as he saw it. I thought it was great that other surfers like Tom Curren and Pottz etc followed his lead but it’s not the same as being the leader. Sadly it has permanently affected my long term view of professional surfers, particularly those who have been paid a fortune by the surf industry yet failed to do anything with their renown other than prettify their own images. For a long time I expected more of them as a result of Tom’s actions, but now, ha.
Oh BTW re the wetsuits, there were no exclusive contracts back then, and Tom was sponsored also by Rip Curl. That was the rubber at JBay.

Nick Dee

Thanks Nick. We are fortunate to have you posting here. I just thought I would rock the boat a little. I did speak to Tom once, when he was shyly walking around Maroubra Beach promoting the 1983 Surfabout with a Cheyne Horan poster (I was a Cheyne supporter). I called Tom over, gave him some cheek but told Tom firmly he would win (which he did). Regards.

Mug Of Sunshine

Media stand against printing anything that might jeopardise their next lanyard/junket or sully them in the eyes of their demigods in board shorts. Those few that eschew this principled position do so with temerity of the Lion from Oz.

Wowen Ilson

Carroll, Curren, Potter and Cheyne Horan boycotting South Africa?

dickie toledo

WSL judges refusal to score style points. Fallout is Ads winning a title

Captain Clark

Is Kaepernick even black? His publicity stunt won’t help the fact that his play sucks and he most likely is out the door next injury.
As to surfing’s biggest stand, I’d say AI. The self induced gauntlet that he threw down, then ran against the king. Epic.

Karl Von Fanningstadt

He’s biracial. Even so, why would that matter?

bitter guy

i guess you have to be of pure slave descent and poor as dirt to have the right to say anything is fucked up around here

Wardo's PO

I do declare my good sir, according to the one-drop rule passed into law by our great forefathers in the south, he is of negro descent. Now, wait a minute, folks. Is you is, or is you ain’t, my constituency?

Mug Of Sunshine

Voting Trump?


33
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x