"Italo... won the first surfing Olympics, battled with form and disillusionment, and just won the best contest since that title at Pipe."
When Nick Carroll speaks it is best to listen. The king of surf journalists, adroit surfer himself, brave, intelligent and brother of Tom, knows a thing or two about a thing or two. Carroll has been writing about this pastime of kings for the better part of five decades yet is as sharp as ever.
And moments ago, he added much gravitas to the growing sentiment that sitting World Surf League champion Filipe Toledo should vacate his slot on Brazil’s Olympic team so that Italo Ferreira can give it a crack. Taking to Surfline and discussing how Teahupo’o has changed, or hasn’t in the past ten years, Carroll penned, “Italo, well in that long decade, he’s come from poverty to a world title, won the first surfing Olympics, battled with form and disillusionment, and just won the best contest since that title at Pipe. Vahine’s now full-on favorite for the approaching Games at what’s pretty much her homebreak. Maybe Filipe should give Italo his spot.”
Mic dropped.
Only the most mentally slovenly surf fan is unaware that Toledo famously fails to paddle at Head Place and, if the waves are good, may well reprise his historic 0.00 heat total there or even that time he got out-surfed by not one but two geriatrics. It is, no doubt, a scary wave with a story of near amputation making the rounds today but Toledo is a champion with cat-like reflexes and lightly more is expected.
The timid lion was in Tahiti, ahead of the just-wrapped Pro won my Ferreira, “training,” as it were, for the Olympics but only shared a video of him not completing a baby barrel.

Again, I am holding out that Toledo is merely roping us all as dopes and will deliver one of, if not the, greatest sporting stories of all time by overcoming fear and mental anguish etc. to win gold.
Nick Carroll thinks otherwise.
To whom will the brave coward listen?
More as the story develops.
Commented on Disqus? Log out, tap the Disqus button, and your old name and comments come back. The box is ours.
Your comments are still here. Every one of them.
Twelve years of BeachGrit comments came across from Disqus. Connect and we will show you how many are yours. We get your username, nothing else.
Connect Disqus to reveal.
🤣🤣🤣
Its pretty useful sometimes
Jealous of Tom ?
I have a limit on how much someone should be kicked when they are down and I’ve reached it .
Pip has been choose via the criteria to surf for Brazil in the Olympics.
I wish him well and care little for some mid sixty years old opinion on who would be better.
Give pip a day or two off.
Like ffs.
Yea. It’s been good fodder and easy target but suddenly feeling pretty dirty. I don’t want blood on my hands!
hmmmm, so maybe we should have brazilian ex world champs comment , and decide which Australians are worthy of the berth they earned in the olympics, and what other Ozzie should be thrown in instead?
Russell Bjierke?
Haha who cares, send Deived Silva, send anyone. Anyone but Pip.
xox
“KING OF SURF JOURNALISTS” may want to check the Olympic rules.
don’t think Olympic athletes have the right (based on the rules) to just go out and give “their spot” to anyone he or lil’ Nicky thinks deserve it. there are actually rules for qualification.
Italo has already been to the Olympics. he had his shot.
Felipe got to the Olympics fair and square. Has Tricky Nicky ever qualified for the Olympics? Nope.
Does Nick the Dick surf as good as Felipe? Nope
Has Nick sucks Dick ever been a world champion? Nope
So Nickola Butthola should STFU.
If Felipe goes and fails, so be it. If Felipe goes and succeeds, so be it.
Let it go, cunts
Isn’t it great when journalists don’t stick to the facts
what’s a fucken journalist?
Nick did say ………..maybe he should?
Then some other creature calls himself a journalist and twists Nicks comment…but we are on BG where truth is novel idea that surfaces occasionally!
If writing rambling memoirs about the hey days of Sydney’s eastern suburb pro surfing set and riding ones brothers coat tails his whole life is journalisn then I guess nicks about there
Not one “surf journalist” has a journalism degree. Nick bangs on about his dad working in the newspaper but big deal. If your dad is a surgeon doesn’t mean you can go chop people up.
I’d argue that a degree is journalism is of little consequence to a person’s skills as a journalist.
I’d also argue that there are precisely zero surf journalists, because there is no appetite for journalism in surfing.
There are surf writers, but not surf journos.
What about my Instagram handle?
Yeah, I did a double major, literature and journalism, to be credentialed, as they say, and the only thing I got out of it was an appreciation for gorgeous, sucky, slutty Madame Bovary.
Agree 100%
Mmmmmm chopping peoples up
Please tell me your dad wasn’t a surgeon!
True. Hard to read stuff nowadays, gotta peel so many layers.
Respectfully brutus, people can say whatever they want, its the internet, but whats the point of a well-credited scribe (or a journalist* if you’re not keen on labeling him as a journalist) writing publicly to his somewhat vast following about something which is not gonna happen, and most importantly can’t actually happen? Unless it was written in these pages, a safe space for inconsistency and speculation.
He’s hating the player not the game. What’s the point?
Especially when the player is currently out of commission due to his inner demons facing this matter. Its just kicking someone who’s already down. Not cool.
Journalist, not.
Nicks jealous of Tom.
Gabs is in, having Italo there is just redundancy.
I am praying that Felipe gives his spot to Italo.
Amen
I am praying Pip wins chopes…just to shut the whingers down!
Could very well be small and or shitty and that may very well happen.
What’s the chance of 2 comps in a row getting good surf?
50% ?
I’m praying for other things personal to my own life and the man up stairs seems to give two shits about the problem. Further more I’m on my second attempt to get two custom boards shaped and can’t get shaper to confirm order even after receiving my deposit. First shaper sent him deposit said he got it and heard nothing 28 days later asked for my money back! Try to support the independent shaper… I get nothing!
now that’s sad when ya consider most shapers need the work…….fuck I hope it wasn’t me?
Sounds like you Brutus.
Will have to join the internet masses and buy a board from Trip..
WWJD?
Tom Carroll probably thinks: Shut up Nick you kook!
Fernando is loving it the best because he knows all he has to do is do nothing and WSL will implode like a Black Hole. Then he gets to run pro surfing as well as rock up to the Olympics every 4 years.
https://media4.giphy.com/me… World Champion Pip! Rrrrraaarrrrr!!…
Forget Pip, if Tahiti pumps for the olympics surely theres going to be a complete shit show of competitors completely unequipped to deal with those type of conditions. Can’t wait!
How’s this for a mic drop:
Italo is ineligible. He cannot compete this year.
You’d reckon the “King of Surf Journalists” would know the fucking rules.
Have you seen how convoluted the rules are for the olympics? I don’t blame him for not knowing.
The trick is reading it back to front about 1000 times. Then it becomes crystal clear! :D
Nick wont even paddle the BG lineup, pussy.
A few have tried—with not good results.
Anybody heard from Ben?
All the cool kids left when Nick and Longtom bailed.
it use to be a pretty good circle jerk of sorts..
Him and Longtom will never be back so long as they have their sweet gig at swellnet with all the nerds. I don’t know why Chas bothers trying to name drop them. They ain’t coming.
theyre all for nerds – oblivous nerds, acceptance nerds or denial nerds
There’s been cameos here and there.
https://uploads.disquscdn.c… The set of tits on the real Nick Carroll are enought to make Sasha-Ryan jealous. Just sayin’.
The clue is on the hat.
Jen that’s irrelevant.
It’s a vibes-based economy now. Brand-recognition is everything.
Here we are, shaking our fist at the clouds. All the while Nick continues to shake two fists at the clouds. We are not worthy.
So, is “that guy” a second cousin of Surfline Man or something?
I was the first to make the mistake! Pioneer!