Bad romance.
I hate to say I told you so, but…actually…wait. That isn’t true at all—I LOVE to say I told you so. And Matt Biolos, if you’ve had occasion to read any of these articles over the last year, I absolutely told you so.
TLDR: the Court in the Lost v. Lady Gaga lawsuit just dismissed Lost’s case and entered judgment in Lady Gaga’s favor.
So how did we get here?
If you recall from the last article on this subject, the Court denied Lost’s motion for preliminary injunction back in December of last year, and its order rebuked Lost’s trademark claims in a manner that telegraphed that Lost’s case was almost certainly doomed. At that time, I opined that if Lost’s lawyers were smart, they’d start trying to negotiate a settlement to avoid further exposure to an attorneys’ fee application by Lady Gaga. As it turns out, Lost’s lawyers ostensibly were not smart, and were determined to carry on with Matt Biolos’s legal crusade.
Critically, Lost did something that made it even easier for Lady Gaga to request dismissal of the lawsuit. This was an application to file a Second Amended Complaint, which the Court allowed Lost to file after denying the motion for a preliminary injunction. However, the Second Amended Complaint added no new allegations whatsoever other than adding a new party as a defendant, making the Second Amended Complaint substantively the same as the First Amended Complaint (which was the one at issue on the motion for preliminary injunction).
This opened the door for Lady Gaga to file a motion to dismiss the Second Amended Complaint, which was filed in January. That motion argued that the entire case should be dismissed because: 1) the Court had already decided in the context of the motion for preliminary injunction that Lady Gaga’s use of the word “Mayhem” was non-infringing because it was expressive and protected by the First Amendment; 2) the Second Amended Complaint added nothing new.
Lost opposed the motion to dismiss, and also requested “leave to amend” (i.e., another chance to file a Third Amended Complaint to add factual allegations to get around these First Amendment issues).
That motion was fully briefed in February of this year, and Judge Olguin once again sat on a fully briefed motion for over six months until its August 18th order on the motion to dismiss.
Unsurprisingly, there really is nothing new in the Court’s order granting Lady Gaga’s motion to dismiss that it did not discuss in denying Lost’s motion for preliminary injunction. What is notable though, is that the Court denied Lost’s request for leave to amend to file a Third Amended Complaint. Ordinarily, leave to amend pleadings is liberally granted, but you do not get infinite chances. Eventually, courts will tell a plaintiff it has had enough chances, and this happens more frequently in federal court.
On that point, Judge Olguin stated as follows:
“Here, plaintiff has had three opportunities to state viable claims. In addition, plaintiff has been on notice of the deficiencies in its Lanham Act claims through meet and confers with opposing counsel, (see Dkt. 50-1, Declaration of Ilissa Samplin in Support of Motion to Dismiss at ¶¶ 7-8), and the Court’s Order of December 15, 2025, identifying those deficiencies. (See Dkt. 41, Court’s Order of December 15, 2025, at 4-6). Plaintiff did not put forth sufficient allegations in the SAC to address those deficiencies. (See, generally, Dkt. 44, SAC). In short, having liberally construed and assumed the truth of the allegations in the SAC, the court is persuaded that giving plaintiff another opportunity to amend would be futile.”
So, the lawsuit has been dismissed, but this is in no way over for Lost and Matt Biolos. Under the Lanham Act, a court can award attorneys’ fees to a prevailing party in “exceptional cases.” There’s also a good chance here that Olguin would issue a fee award given that he dismissed the case before it ever really got off the ground.
Lady Gaga’s attorneys are almost certain to file a fee motion because the worst that can happen is that the Court just denies the request. The worst that can happen for Lost, on the other hand, would be a far grimmer fate. If Lady Gaga’s fees are awarded, they are going to exceed $1 million with a firm like Gibson Dunn at Lady Gaga’s helm.
Can Lost even afford to pay that? Will this be the end of Lost Surfboards as we know it?
I have no idea, but I imagine that a standup, God-fearing, MAGA supporter like Matt Biolos will point the finger at his counsel, sue them for malpractice, and hope that his counsel’s malpractice insurance carrier will pay some or all of any fee award Lady Gaga might receive. And that would perhaps be the first smart decision Biolos has made in this case. Matt, get at me on Insta if you want referrals for legal malpractice attorneys in Orange County.
Lost could of course appeal, but I highly doubt the Ninth Circuit would reverse this decision. Even then, a pending appeal would not stop Lady Gaga from filing an attorneys’ fee motion and then collecting a fee award against Lost unless Lost posts a bond that would cover the fee award and convinces the Ninth Circuit to stay (i.e., pause) the enforcement of the fee award pending the appeal (also unlikely).
If Lady Gaga files a fee motion and/or if Lost appeals, I will report back. If not, this bad romance of a lawsuit was certainly amusing, at least in the pre-judgment phase.
Commented on Disqus? Log out, tap the Disqus button, and your old name and comments come back. The box is ours.
Your comments are still here. Every one of them.
Twelve years of BeachGrit comments came across from Disqus. Connect and we will show you how many are yours. We get your username, nothing else.
Connect Disqus to reveal.
The word itself, Mayhem, leads to that style of lettering. Many people are saying that it was a strongly waste money that was very powerfully given away. No one else could have done it. It’s quite possibly the most powerfully and strongly lawsuit ever filed.
I thought the 2nd amendment was about guns???
how is biolos the only person that didn’t see this clusterfuck coming?
even as a ‘there’s no such thing as bad publicity’ stunt, it’s still bad.
Did Lost sue the printing machine company in your hypothetical?
It does look like it was copied…. but cmon lost….. be cool and not care about that corpo crap… just go surf. PS i love lost boards and have several.
Looking for my copy and I found Sons of Fun and Pump
My fave film, In the Wind, I can not find even in Storage
or they’re a bogan who just can’t read very well 🤷♂️
Lemme edit it down for you.
…Lost lose lurid$1m lawsuit. Lady Gaga lavished with legal loot
Can’t stand either Gaga or Biolos. Can’t they both lose?
Andrew Tate and his brother getting locked up, Chris Ward hawking some attrocious tale pad that has like a 6′ kick on it (hard and soft) called RIKT, and now this. Its been a tough couple months for Lost and its riders.
Chris was the star of the video I mention below with Strider
I laughed at the time, been in that club and it was ridiculous, but things were permissible that would be skewered today
You should watch Ward Stories.
I don’t like the guy
That seems to be a pretty common consensus.
Good one Com
“Mayhem” is expressive and protected by the 1st, but still the graphics look so similar, it doesn’t seem like a big leap to say Gaga’s group copied Lost’s graphic design.
but they never registered the design—only the word “Mayhem.”
who fucking cares?
Biolos was a massive dumb cunt trying this on.
Solid write up Com.
So good to get such a smart take on such a stupid lawsuit.
very nice work Com , definitely the most informative coverage of this saga that will appear across the surf media universe (and I truly mean that in the least sarcastic sense possible).
and no hints of AI slop detected , ha!!
once again, BG revealing the brains underneath the blowhards
just saw that Lost’s attorney has publically said that Lost intends to appeal, so the saga continues!
Gibson Dunn quaking in their boots , i’m sure
at least Matt appears to be taking it well…
https://uploads.disquscdn.c…
would be interesting to hear what he thinks is really going on and what info he might have been provided that makes him think that way
if he’s dumb enough to discuss the privileged attorney-client communications he’s had with his counsel, I’ll certainly do another article breaking that down
one day Sam M will pull it out of him – part of their new series , “How Shapers Get Screwed”
It should be more like, “How Shapers Screw Themselves”
All shapers end up insane or broke
Zero chance anyone at The Inertia has Biolos’ phone number.
He …lost
https://uploads.disquscdn.c…
Lady Saga
Shady Gaga
tell you what, AI in my world gets better every time I turn it on, strap in for the ride
actually agree with you. Use it every day to compile and organize big chunks of info and data. Wouldnt use it yet for anything I write for public consumption but as a tool it’s getting better and better.
I can’t imagine reading this for a living Com
Not sure what Mayhem does for Lady Gaga either
Is the definition of Mayhem a shaping machine and sanders finishing boards?
Or was it Strider looking up young girls dresses while they danced at Squid Row?
wait, you can get paid to read BeachGrit for a living?
I love your explanations, but they are over my pay grade.
My brother once said he wanted to be an Attorney at a family dinner. “You don’t like to read and you don’t comprehend that which you do read”.
My mom giggled, yeah, it requires a lot of dry reading.
Instead, he’s a failed actor ( probably because he didn’t read the script?)
Com, did you ever see the OG lost video with Strider?
Full Epstein shit.
never saw that one. surprised Matt didn’t release a 30th anniversary edition though!
Sterile Strider doesn’t want it shown, for sure
You gotta find it
Was this in Cabo or another one? I think the Cabo vids were called “Ward Stories” and were put out late 2000’s early 2010’s. I remember watching them on surfline which leans 2000’s for me.
What about …lost across America?
this was mid 90’s
Cory, Strider and Wardo
“Why aren’t you on tour Strider?”
What’s really going wrong and/ or what’s really going on?
“Grandpa, he’s a dirty old man!”
Just skim the citations like I do!
Skim skimma… who’s got the keys to my Bima!
My middle name must be “fuck you”…
you’ll Bee dat!
Wasn’t he saying “”eleventeen” over and over…