Jen See takes on the story everyone's talking about!
This morning I rode my Schwinn to the coffee shop with The New York Times Magazine clutched under my arm. Almost immediately it began to rain, so there I was carrying a paper magazine in the rain. This was not good planning. There is, it seems, something to be said for carrying a 10 thousand word feature in a glowing metal and glass box tucked safely into your pocket.
I arrived to a packed scene and sardined my way to the counter to order. After scavenging a chair, I tucked under the awning with my macchiato to read this week’s cover story, Daniel Duane’s delicious feature on women’s big wave surfing.
They had me at the subhead, which calls big-wave surfing “one of the most dangerous, rapturous sports on Earth.” I’m not sure this is true, never having experienced it myself, but it would have lured me straight into reading the story — even if I hadn’t already heard talk of some pure fire interview quotes from the women involved.
At length and in full-dress New York Times Magazine feature style, Duane traces the efforts of women such as Bianca Valenti and Keala Kennelly to gain admittance to the big wave boys club. This is a story that’s been begging to be told. It has all the best ingredients: colorful characters, nature at its most wild and unpredictable, a near-constant risk of death, and maybe best of all, men behaving badly.
The story’s sympathies are clear. The women come off as uniformly badass and determined. Valenti describes riding a wave at Jaws as feeling as one of “peacefulness” as though “this is where I was meant to be.” If you’ve wondered what compels surfers to throw themselves down mountains of water, Duane does as good work as anyone has at illuminating the seductive draw of big waves to those who chase them.
The juice of the story is the resistance that women have encountered in gaining access to big wave lineups, contests, and prize money. Here, the surf industry and the assorted contest organizers, from Jeff Clark at Mavericks to the WSL, do not come off especially well. The sexism appears to run deeply and Duane does not pull his punches. Men appear largely dismissive of women’s abilities and view them as rivals for prize money at best and as dangers in the lineup at worst.
Kennelly’s outspoken comments, in particular, had me cackling out loud. She describes the surf industry as she found it in the early 2000’s, when she was surfing on the CT, as teeming with “creepy team managers.” There’s more, and the story is worth reading for Kennelly’s unflinching excoriation of the surf industry as she experienced it. Duane shows the price she paid for the industry’s close-mindedness at the time as sponsors dropped her and she struggled to find support.
The WSL and their much-ballyhooed equal prize money initiative also fall short of the mark in this account. Some of this ground is familiar as Duane retraces the reporting of the San Jose Mercury News on Goldschmidt’s description of the women’s “poor performance” and abuse of #metoo. When placed in the context of the longer story, the WSL looks a lot more like an continuation of surfing’s old order than the fabulously shiny, new thing they like to portray themselves as.
Duane’s given us an inspiring story of guts and glory, the kind of thing that’s perfect for a rainy Sunday morning. Here’s a group of women, who didn’t fit within the narrow boundaries that the surf industry, or the wider culture for that matter, wanted to draw for them. So they set out to obliterate those boundaries. Duane, rightly I think, gives Kennelly the kicker. I’m not going to spoil it, except to say that it’s worth reading all the way to the end.
Chris Dixon and Frank: please email [email protected] from the address you'd like your BeachGrit login on.
Commented on Disqus? Log out, tap the Disqus button, and your old name and comments come back. The box is ours.
Your comments are still here. Every one of them.
Twelve years of BeachGrit comments came across from Disqus. Connect and we will show you how many are yours. We get your username, nothing else.
Connect Disqus to reveal.
You are so right. The surf media has been complicit in their silence as the surf industry sold out the local surf industry and local surf shops by taking their manufacturing and production of their products overseas to take advantage of cheap labor.
Surfing trophy for wipeouts? Shouldn’t it be a wipeout trophy for surfing? Confusing, the bizarre post-modern neomarxist pro-surf universe. Now that would make for a good article. Toss in some Jung.
Sorry, never miss the chance to register your opinion?
At least the article wasn’t completely self centered and peppered with name dropping.
Oh I did! Strange, but true.
Upvote because I knew this is exactly what you’d say and I was worried you’d missed the opportunity.
I think it is sick that pro women in surfing, or snowboarding, or skiing or any skill sport (figure skating, skateboarding!) are sicker than 95% of the male population. But the big difference in the last 5% at the professional level is always going to be a very wide margin unless athletes are genetically altered at birth, with higher testosterone levels, altered body development but still tech female, but also very male chemically bone density, etc. Sort of what china does to its athletes. Only way line is blurred, it’s not really comparative at the top 5% of skill levels at the lower level it is where pro women regularly outshine us average joes. And that is eye opening, and awesome and inspiring for young women, but also find me dudes who can surf as aesthetically beautiful as a steph gilmore? Isn’t femininity something to be admired as well, in the style of sports?
women: there is sexism
men: no, there isn’t!
women: *eye roll*
It comes down to interest and marketability. It doesn’t garner the same level of attention as men. By your own argument, a women’s NFL league should command more pay. Look at the WNBA, they don’t fill seats the wAy the men do, therefore the venture is not as profitable. If a women’s company, were to take the reigns and offer a proper prize purse equal to the men, I would wager it would not see as many eyeballs and therefore not be seen as a win vs the capital invested. The culture around it does not posses the reach of the men. MMA is the same, as are most pro sports, and until society can wrap their heads around the nuances you’re describing, it will not be a viable model. Do it for the love of what you do, not because you think there’s a living to be made.
When Billabong stopped sponsoring KK because they deemed her as unmarketable as a gay woman, I thought what a lack of imagination! Women are the main consumers of beachwear apparel. They could’ve expanded their brand. Every woman surfer has a little tomboy in her. But what do you expect from an industry that’s run by sexist white men.
They are massive consumers. However, if billabong seems her unmarketable, that’s because they feel that they have a better avenue that would resonate with their end consumer. KK speaks to a smaller audience, and being honest, I don’t think her style (clothing/fashion) was inline with the brand. The other side of the coin is Clay Marzo, as I had heard he was let go from Spy and Quiksilver around the same time. He is an incredible talent, but didn’t photograph well with shades, so there was a different option taken. He has asperbergers and incredible talent, but he too fell victim to the brand…..
I was cheering inside as I read his article (and mentally fact checking all the little details); awesome job on the interviews and by the way, go girls!!
And what about creepy unwanted beard-stroking and neck-patting amongst celebrity surf journalists at expos?
Why does no one ever cover that?!?!
There’s a lot to cover in weirdo surf world.
As I read the article I just kept thinking that Jeff Clark comes off way more like a Utah Mormon than a California Mormon.
I do think the sexism thing can be a little overcooked–essentially women big wave surfers demand a separate admittance into big wave events because they are women. If they were deserving of spots on their merits and denied simply because they are women that’d be one thing. But that is not the case. My non-surfing friends and family come away from this with ‘women big wave surfers are discriminated against but they pushed through ala Jackie Robinson’ which isn’t really accurate if we’re being honest.
That said women’s big wave surfing is great, should be supported, they surf big waves a lot better than me etc. And the industry as a whole seems super sexist in so many ways. So it’s all to the good.
The youth will never respect their elders, and it’s likely getting worse.
But hey, that’s evolutionary biology for you!
Watch how the liquid gets into the chalk
https://youtu.be/8d6mQG_QzNw
It really does get in.
“Watch this father and son pose fo…”
https://trc.taboola.com/bea…
Biology ,respect,evolution and the elderly
https://youtu.be/rF5lNuF6vM0
Julius might have been better advertising Coke ?
Are you going through a Cretaceous Period ?
Hang on while i google that
No, cretinous.
Ok . I’ll chalk it up .
I think this has more to do with how often law enforcement gets involved these days than evolution.
I had one problem with the NYT page. I don’t watch much big wave surfing so am ignorant – maybe this is the where big wave surfing is at: the vid at the top of the article. Big wave yes, but not really surfed, like the rider stands up and goes over the ledge and straight down the face to lose all the speed the wave gave them and wait for the whitewater to hit. Looks a bit shit.
didn’t Sarge get rumbled by Fred Pawles story in STAB?
spill the beans Goat.
I need a pick up today.
Are these women absolutely delusional? How can they say they honestly deserve more money or spots in the lineup? Did anyone watch the women at jaws and compare it to the men? Stop getting your hopes up ladies…
Apparently, they deemed the waves too dangerous to surf and shut down the men’s contest after only one heat so what are talking about? No one was able to get down the face of the wave without wiping out. After the contest Kai put on a display of some amazing surfing but he was towed in.
Nah I disagree Lemoore, the greatest form of discrimination is straight up discrimination.
Schwinns rule! Older the better!
1956 Tornado!
Sick! Do a wheelie down State Street with that sucker!
Ha ha, fuck, it is made from like solid steel. I don’t think I could get the front wheel much more than like, two inches off the road!
Yes worth every moment spent reading to the very end , and then i fucked it up by reading about that little creep Taj and its fucked my zen.