This avenging angel function of the White shark has raised its status as an environmental icon, above that of the whale, the dolphin, even the intriguing old man of the forest, the Orangutan.
Misanthropy is as old as the hills, from the moment we crawled out of the sludge hatred of our brothers and sisters has been a constant companion.
We all love a little revenge fantasy, from Cain and Abel to De Niro’s Trav Bickle who famously wished for a cleansing rain to rid the streets of “human scum and filth” revenge fantasies have offered succour to our sense of fragile aggrievement.
We all pine somewhere in our heart of hearts for an avenging angel to restore justice, no matter how misplaced that sense of justice might be.
Read any below the line commentary on a White shark attack story, no matter the source and it becomes perfectly clear that the White shark has become the post-modern avenging angel du jour.
“Cull fucking humans”
“Humans are a cancer on the Earth that needs eradication” etc etc – is the gist of it.
The latest attack is usually less than a day old before those comments are delivered with a misanthropic glee. This avenging angel function of the white shark has raised its status as an environmental icon, above that of the whale, the dolphin, even the intriguing old man of the forest, the orangutan. In this world view the white shark is a way of being, a cypher, a means of understanding and taking revenge on a human created world gone mad.
Judge, jury and righteous executioner.
Despite the misanthropic undertone post-attack the focus of shark public relations is on rehabilitation of the image of White shark as violent offender. Jaws author Peter Benchley, as reaction to the fear unleashed by his creation, led the PR effort, declaring after the 2001 fatal White shark attack on Ken Crews: “I can say absolutely that the shark was not acting with malice towards the man; not with intent to do bodily harm…”
This omniscience into the mind of the shark is a curious feature of most shark writing, even those of a scientific bent.
The leading shark conservationist gals like Ocean Ramsey in Hawaii and Madison Stewart in Australia are expert in this linguistic trick, casually maintaining the White shark is cautious and curious and any bite is just an unfortunate mistake.
I don’t begrudge these gals their living as white shark experts, they are, as Beck sang on Mellow Gold, “goddesses milking the time for all that it’s worth”.
And if they can make a hundred fifty US dollars for a download on how to avoid shark attack, then that counts as an honest living in my books.
Intense contradictory feelings cloud my judgement on this issue. I’m down with the White shark as avenging angel, but I wish the target was soccer mums and not my pals.
Terrible thoughts, I know.
My bairn wanted a go out at the Point this week. There’s no-one down the inside section. The White shark has created space which I am happy to inhabit. Four wheeling, fizzing constellations of bait balls getting hit by meso-predators erupt in spray showers within a hundred metres.
The feeding frenzies slip in and out of the sand bank. In the near distance I can see half a dozen late migrating humpbacks, the sound of over-sized pectoral fins slapping the water arrives a half second after the vision. Situation normal for around here.
If you avoided surfing when bait or whale were visible you’d never paddle out.
My boyo gets the wave of his life.
Another one.
Looking back I am blinded by the glare. I hear screaming.
I can hear “Dad! Dad!”.
Blood turns to ice as I sprint paddle towards the screaming.
It’s a fin chop. He wants another one.
I see a pal who was in the water when Mani was fatally attacked. Another, also present, was absent. He suffers post-traumatic stress. They worked on Mani for an hour before the paramedics arrived. It came first for one leg, then hit him again on the other. Had to be prised away from the teenager.
My pal cannot come to terms with it. The bite and spit, the “cautious” animal who had made a mistake and bore no malice; that means nothing to him now. All he remembers are the eyes of the boy. They were open, but lifeless, like the eyes of a fish pulled out of an icebox.
I can’t deny the frisson of death, the senses working overtime is a panacea, a cleansing rain, to what Rimbaud called the “horror of home”.
I’ll take this flight of fancy; this danger serrated with an Abrahamic edge over the vortex of tech addiction any day.
We paddle out because that’s what we do.
Amor Fati. Love of fate propels us onwards.
Is there higher than normal ocean productivity in the area where these attacks have been concentrated?
I thought whales had flippers, not fins?
Amazing piece LT.
I have noting but awe that you paddle out at the point in the infested north coast waters. I could feel the anxiety of having the bairn with you each sesh. you and he a gnarly and same goes for the other locals who don’t mind being bait. Please stay safe!
Top points for the Scottish reference. Nay fook’n bairns in the puuoob!
The WSL could hold a ten comp world title tour in a bubble in Bali
There are so many good waves in different spots.
Even a comp at canguu would be epic, ulus, padang, bingin keramas, desert point, Sanur, etc.
They could do it in ten weeks, all on business visa. fukk how good would it be
See Bali is riddled with ass flu now. They let inter-island travel and that fucked it.
“Had the Experience but Missed the Meaning “
T.S Eliot
You sure pack in the literary quotes LT…. I like when I have to read something twice to digest it, sweet.
Look, the fish are eating us, why can’t we fish them again?
ahhh yes, nothing quite like broad reach surfing open ocean waves on a sunny day …
Fuck i hope some stupid shark doesn’t turn this man into shorttom I enjoy his writing way to much for that.
There were two Asian guys snorkeling in DY lagoon today.
That’s brave.
Lotta bull action in there?
Mainly at the pub
timo
Programmed by recent events to assume the worst …. thank fuck LT , it was a fin chop on your boy and not a fin chomp !
I was in Jerusalem in 91 and I saw two men carrying a plank , with a sheet on top , to a van …. I told my sister and her friend to look away …. thinking the worst …… and then a huge sigh of relief when it turned out that were only setting up a food stand on a Saturday Night Market as the sun went down to end the Sabbath ….
The bit where you sprint paddle to your boy nicely captures how the situation is affecting folk. Clean a few other bits up and I fully expect Karl V-F to grade this article ‘B+’ or even ‘A’ the next time you write it.
The other situation, which I have not heard mention of too much, is the additional mental toll being taken on the surfers in those areas. Apart from the obvious, it’s the ‘weight’ of the constant hyper-awareness adds on to what is/was a physically testing, yet mentally refreshing activity. My experience of a short, less than an hour, surf at a bank in front of the Lennox pub a couple of years ago, felt like a 3 hour surf. The mate I surfed with that day, has said the same thing. After the emergence from restrictions, he has only had access to the beaches within that region where previously he was travelling further afield through work. He says that he surfs far less time, and doesn’t get the same sense of ‘wholesomeness’ after a surf.
Kahlils girlfriends cousins mates business associates might be interested in some fins to help keep the numbers down…
My kenya friend/ex roommate was gobbled up whole at poliholi kauai 2 summers ago. Sunset bath 4 yards from the shoreline at dusk. I am glad poli is closed now. Think of how many lives have been saved. Sure He was a barny from Michigan, falling in love w Hawaii. But the new grill and white ladies were to much for His karma load? His saying was ” like a shark in the sea, as free as can be”. I was scared for a few months until I finally heard who the victim was. Now He became shark poop.
details? Never heard of someone dying at Polihale of shark attack
I’m not sure if there’s been deaths at Polihale but I do know there’s been some legs taken at Davidson’s near Kekaha. Mike Coots lost a leg at Major’s Bay next to Polihale in 1997. Check out his excellent video.
https://youtu.be/BqIduefkijk
here’s Mike and Bethany https://uploads.disquscdn.c…
Pilot landing on the base told my wife how many large sharks were just off the outside tip at Majors. Waves were pumping, I had not a care in the world, but the MP’s alerted me when I went to sign out.
This sums up the current situation
https://uploads.disquscdn.c…
The cautious pragmatism of the noble Stoics might certainly have kept them from paddling out, whereas the hedonistic Epicureans, those pleasure-seeking souls entirely untroubled by fears of death, would be dominating the lineup, laughing and scoring all the shacks.
In other words, sack up you pussies. Quit yer ruminating. This is the price we pay.
Ask Bethany Hamilton how she feels about it.
“People ain’t no good”. The Cramps 1986.
Can your Pussy do the Shark ?
Woof. Meow?
Can your pussy do the dog . The Cramps sang way back when ?
Pitched the book yet?
If not, this is my 2 cents: make it character profiles of the people who were killed and the witnesses and families left, like you describe here.
A book about humans, not a book about sharks.
What a crock of shit.
More people die every ten minutes from catching the virus while shopping at Walmart than all your shark attacks in a year.
Whinging Aussies.
Ffs
I wonder if a violent death was easier back in the days when it happened all the time? My thoughts go out to those who lost their lives, their family/friends, and those that has to paddle out in such terrifying waters.
Funny you mention it, I’ve been reading the comments in MSM re sharks and the overwhelming joe public sentiment seems to be ‘surfers are entering the shark’s habitat, they know the risks’
The simple counter argument is, for example, imagine if an explosion in brown snake population started seeing ppl getting bitten and dying in council park lands, would you not cull the snakes?
But overall I reckon the dream of some PR-led campaign to cull isn’t happening any time soon. The needle has not shifted.
The PR led cull campaign will ONLY happen when some poor cunt gets ripped apart between the red and yellow this summer!!!
Or if one gets a hold of a junior clubbie nipper.
https://www.change.org/Redu…
Or surf school ?
Lenny folkard wouldn’t have been far from the flags. I still remember being ordered in from newy that arvo due to multiple large sharks being spotted by the westpac in close proximity. Beaches closed for 15 days straight. Yet here we are.
hmm but it will prob take a swimmer to make it happen – in bondi manly maybe not here so much another on goldie for sure??
I recall that summer was fun too. Beaches closed over the chrissy/NY break. Crazy times. I was at the cliff pre-bathers way makeover one day checking it during the closures and another bloke I didn’t know was there.
Clean little peaks, options weighed up and we both agreed it was on, we’d chance it. Hour latter crew galore were laughing and descending the steps.
Was a good hour, anxiety minimal a few sneaky looks at my feet in the crystal clear water between getting busy in uncrowded summer cliff peaks. Was nothing compared to what LT and nth coast crew have to weigh up each paddle out.
Non surfers think that going surfing is a choice. They will never understand.
Surfing for the truly addicted is like breathing , it is not a conscious decision or choice …. it’s automatic for the survival of the surfing individual ?
It’s disgusting the comments I read on a thrashy online news outlet here whenever a shark attack happens. If I took the same victim blaming attitude towards victims of sexual crimes I would be lynched – and rightly so!
I just got torn to shreds by shark huggers for suggesting more needs to be done to protect human life on the Nine and abc FB pages regarding the attack in QLD. Some tranny was saying shark life is above human life so I told her that next time she go in the water I hope a shark bites her dick off.