Advertisement

WSL in legal stoush with Women’s Independent Soccer League over latter’s trademark registration!

The WISL is dedicated to furthering women’s equality in soccer, “a league created by women for women” and “an equality project.”

Earlier this month, the World Surf League (WSL) challenged the trademark registration of the Women’s Independent Soccer League (WISL).

The WISL is dedicated to furthering women’s equality in soccer. The league will operate as a secondary, sort of minor league for the National Women’s Soccer League, providing women a path to pro soccer.

The WISL is self-described as “a league created by women for women” and “an equality project.”

The WISL was founded in response to the flourishing of Major League Soccer (MLS), the top men’s soccer league in the US. According to Soccer Today, “Our U.S. Soccer Women’s National Team is the most successful in the world and can proudly claim four FIFA World Cup titles. The men cannot even claim a final match and yet today there are three professional men’s leagues in the USA and several large lower-level leagues as well.”

Advertisement

In April of last year, the WISL announced its first club, the Los Angeles Force, which already has a men’s team.

As you may know, the WSL has long made gender equality a cornerstone of its image. In September 2018, it announced that it would award equal prize money to male and female athletes, making it the self-described “first and only US based global sports league . . . to achieve prize money equality.”

But, recent months have revealed cracks in the equality façade. Questionable decisions in the Pipeline contest, leading noted surf writers to question the WSL’s motivations and one female pro to claim, “It was a fucking joke and a disgrace to all equality in sports pushes ever.”

Then, current Men’s Longboard champ Joel Tudor, delicately as ever, pointed out the WSL’s alleged failure to pay its women’s longboarders at a rate commiserate with their worth.

Advertisement

“They use women’s longboarding to promote everything,” said Tudor.

The Trademark Trial and Appeal Board is currently hearing the dispute.

Will the WSL strike another blow against equality?

More soon.

0 0 votes
Article Rating

Commented on Disqus? Log out, tap the Disqus button, and your old name and comments come back. The box is ours.

Join the discussion

Your comments are still here. Every one of them.

Twelve years of BeachGrit comments came across from Disqus. Connect and we will show you how many are yours. We get your username, nothing else.

Unclaimed
Handle
Comments
Posting since

Connect Disqus to reveal.

Subscribe
Notify of
25 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Who's Your Jaddy

WISL rhymes with weasel?

notsurfingtoday

Legal shittalking aside, after they rebranded to wsl whenever I typed wsl on google, first thing that came up was, always, Women’s Soccer League. This went on for months. Some fucked up SEO from the CEO.

justiceminister

True. Reminiscent of the legal dispute many years ago between the World Wildlife Fund and the World Wrestling Foundation which ended up in a victory for the animals. Maybe some compo as well to the Fund.

Piskian
Simsurf

Who else is rooting for the WISL?

channelbottom

Stickers available soon for discerning BG community members, upon application. https://uploads.disquscdn.c…

NEGATRON

Haha you legend! just got home from a Weekend away and found them in the mailbox!! Cheers!

channelbottom

Sharing is Caring

FelipesFrontFoot

Sticker me!

ValiantScorn

Who is offering the blow?

disqus_00d1gIXedO

Fernando Aguirre

Low wide stinkbug stance

So now ww know the reason for the name change to wsl; the ATP were going to sue the ASP.

Sit down to pee

Presumably they are challenging on the basis of the word mark WSL and not the logos or the full name World Surf League? On that basis I’d say WSL have a good chance. Otherwise they’re going to lose, words like World and League are descriptive and therefore insufficiently distinctive to be capable of registration without acquired distinctiveness which given the WSL is hardly known by anyone outside of surfing seems unlikely to be enough to stop a soccer league.

It’s completely normal for trade mark owners to challenge new registrations, would be pointless to own the trade mark if they didn’t.

Speaking as a recovering ex IP lawyer…

Huli Opu

If you came into my courtroom with that kind of idiotic summation on trademark infringement and dilution I’d immediately find you in contempt and send you back to law school with additional lessons on grammar and syntax. It’s no wonder you need to sit down and pee.

notsurfingtoday

Judge jury and executioner !

Sit down to pee

Go on then explain yourself judge or sit on the bench.

Huli Opu

I direct the jury to disregard counselor’s outburst. May the record reflect that any more nonsense from him or anyone else and I’ll have the bailiff remove you from my courtroom.

Now let’s proceed and call the next witness.

Sit down to pee

I seem to have inadvertently really got under your skin. Sorry about that grandad.

Captain Wack

I can see the similarities

@surfads

Also Dave Wassel better lawyer up

@surfads
Andy Aames

Interesting how the US Women’s team always shits all over the men’s team as a way of proving they deserve more money. There’s a very easy way to settle this. A one off match between the US men and the US women, winner take all. The women shouldn’t have a problem with this as they are a much stronger team than the US men.

Erik Bogan

The US womens soccer team, lost to an under 15 boys Dallas Boys team.
The US mens team would put a cricket score on them.
It’s an interesting read about the men v women soccer pay, the women complained they don’t get paid enough yet rejected the offer to be paid the same as the men

MyGFsChinese

The USMNT has been an embarrassment for as long as I can remember. Choke choke choke choke choke.

They resorted to scheduling a qualifier against Honduras in February in Minneapolis for Christ’s sake. That’s Minnesota. In February. Aainst Honduras. The wind chill at kick off was below zero. Now, that’s not Brazil, that’s fucking Honduras.

It gets worse though. In this cycle, they were smoked by Canada 2-0, tied Jamaica 1-1, and barely squeaked by El Salvador 1-0. If you remember, we lost to TRINIDAD AND TOBAGO in a must-win to actually qualify for the last WC. I could go on. The island nation of TRINIDAD AND TOBAGO has a population of 1.4 million.

Meanwhile, the women are fucking world class and have the World Cup trophies to prove it. As for TV ratings, a quick google search informs that in 2019, the women’s team’s most-viewed game was the England match which had 758,000 viewers, while the men’s most viewed match was the CR game which drew 652,000 viewers. I’m sure if you looked at viewership for the women’s WC finals games, they destroy the amount of viewers the men pull for their shit games. A normal Men’s team game draws more viewers on Telemundo than it does on ESPN, and if you’ve ever attended a US/Mex game in person, you’d know we are overwhelmed by Mexican fans every single time. So, yes, the men’s team would most certainly beat the women’s team in a match, but in terms of money and viewership—the women kick the men’s ass and it’s not really close.

TLDR your point sucks big dicks

Andy Aames

My comment was in reference to a quote in the article:
“Our U.S. Soccer Women’s National Team is the most successful in the world and can proudly claim four FIFA World Cup titles. The men cannot even claim a final match and yet today there are three professional men’s leagues in the USA and several large lower-level leagues as well.”

The two teams achievements are being compared directly. Four world cups vs zero world cups. They do not mention that in the women’s tournaments the level of competition is absolutely atrocious. Very few countries even have women’s soccer teams. It’s apples and oranges, you yourself admit it. Why do you think it’s ok for the women to constantly compare themselves to the men’s team? The only reason they do it is for leverage. It’s completely disingenuous.

Concacaf teams always schedule games to make it as inconvenient to the visiting team as possible. It’s nothing new and is not limited to the US men’s national team.


25
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x