Any sport, anytime, anywhere.
We now know, more than ever, that in our modern world words have the power to hurt. I felt hurt when old mate from Zig Zag said BeachGrit were snark merchants and the comments were where “human hope comes to die”.
That seems not just unfair, but untrue. Hold that thought, please.
I know Chas has already had a swing at the following subject but it does deserve, I think, a story all it’s own.
After much research and deliberation I think we can make the claim, and have it both true and fair, that the 2019 Tahiti Pro had the worst commentary in the History of Sport.
Any sport, anytime, anywhere.
The big day before the finals was a true gift to the WSL as a sporting spectacle. The last such day was 2014.
Five long years ago. Five years in professional surfing is an epoch.
Five years ago the WSL did not exist.
Five years ago there was no Willian Cardoso, no Yago Dora, Wade Carmichael, Ricardo Cristie, Kanoa Igarashi.
Five years ago Filipe Toledo sat out Teahupo’o with an ankle injury.
For a professional league that has now laid on, what I call the narrative pivot, and considers itself, in the words of 2IC Pat O’Connell to be in the “business of telling stories” never has so much ripe material for commentary gone so unremarked.
A truly stunning negation of reality.
Ross Williams was the best of a truly woeful bunch but his fallback line “There are no easy draws on Tour, everyone is a weapon” sounded more and more peculiar as events transpired.
He first employed it as Kanoa Igarashi was giving a tepid performance, that was far from the worst of the day. A generous appraisal is that he was just thoughtlessly repeating a rote phrase.
The actual story was the exact opposite: here we had an actual world title contender who had not been tested in heavy water and was being found wanting, right in front of our eyes.
The story of the coral was comic.
Of course we want Coral Gardeners; not a pre-school kiddie between the Tropics of Cancer and Capricorn should be allowed to start school until they have mastered the art*. But to have the wozzle send in Joey and Kaipo as the pitch men, and call the play by play was…..it seems too snarky to call it weird.
Whatever is weirder than weird. Joe calling the glowing coral a “cry for help”; there is no precedent in the annals of sports commentary.
Barton was woeful. During the insane Italo/ADS heat Italo’s first wave was ridden in silence.
Action: Adriano De Souza standing tall in a huge watery cavern, one of the best waves ridden in five years.
Commentary (BL): So they literally take the coral and put it into the bamboo and let it sprout?”
(Lea Brassy): “Yeah!”
Missed: an eight-point ride from Italo (Interview with Bourez).
Missed: another eight-point ride from Italo (his best).
Missed the start of another one.
Missed the start of ADS’ heat-winning wave.
BL: “I can’t stop smiling (laughs) These are the days you dream of being a pro surfer (Cardoso safety surfs a shoulder without remark). It’s hard to get to the point of talking about coral but how was it for you?”
If I am being snarky, can you find me another example of a sport that on its day of days so spectacularly loses touch with the play by play?
I spent the weekend searching, looking through thousands of hours of You-tube videos and cannot.
There are clips of commentator gaffes, clips where a guy misses a Touchdown conversion and the commentator claims he kicks it, but nowhere does the commentary completely lose touch with the action.
Medina’s ten-point ride: “I was watching that interview more than the wave and enjoying Jeremy’s insights” (BL).
He missed the days only ten-point ride!
I don’t want to be unfair. I don’t want to trade in snark.
Is it over-reach to claim a new, world-historical low has been reached?
There’s an exchange somewhere between BL and Joe, about Owen and helmets and coral that is better that anything Monty Python every wrote.
And it’s serious.
Real sports have oversight committees or arms-length commentary. It feels terrible to flog this dead horse we all love so much for putting on free live surfing for us to watch, but how could they blow it this badly?
And, what was your favourite piece of commentary gold from the day of days?
I will never get past the “cry for help”.
My shameful secret: the worse it gets, the more I enjoy it.
One more: have we now officially entered the post-sport phase of professional surfing?
*A bootie ban in tropical waters is surely the best way to save corals. Keep schlubs from stepping all over it.
Chris Dixon and Frank: please email [email protected] from the address you'd like your BeachGrit login on.
Commented on Disqus? Log out, tap the Disqus button, and your old name and comments come back. The box is ours.
Your comments are still here. Every one of them.
Twelve years of BeachGrit comments came across from Disqus. Connect and we will show you how many are yours. We get your username, nothing else.
Connect Disqus to reveal.
Now now progoatboater, now now.
The hawaiians do it the best, funny and relevant. Check the last shootout.
I’m not watching surf contests for the commentary. All I need to hear is “So and so’s dropping in” or “That was a great wave” so I can look up from whatever I’m doing to see what just went down. If I want colorful opinions about a surf contest I can listen to a podcast that has the benefit of hindsight, or read Beachgrit. I don’t want to miss a decent wave in a heat, but It’s nice that I can tune out and do laundry too- with the help of commentators who don’t demand my full attention through all the boring lulls.
exactly
The issue with surf commentary is simply ….having surfers fill in the long and domineering gaps. Stats don’t keep me awake and Ross and Kelly’s insights can hold me for about 5 minutes tops – and I just don’t surf sand-dunes. I find trying to get into the heads of surfers while they are waiting for waves a dreary exercise – these are not chess-masters (maybe Medina and Kelly can castle) The camera angles during flashes of action are rarely close enough or detailed enough to do in depth performance analysis, and running two waves side by side only ever makes sense at Old McDonald’s Surf Farm.
The WSL have sold us a perfect stage to fill with advertising – long gaps with very little to fill them. The problem is that all the scheduled, predictable commercial and interest fillers too often clash with those unpredictable moments of brilliance that we are putting up with this crap to see.
So faced with 95% waffle and 5% action where do we go? Maybe only the surfer does know the feeling, and highlights are better for the rest of us. The live feed is dead….(at least it smells that way)
Yes, they should have done better. On the other hand, it’s a short one manoeuvre wave.
There is not a lot to talk about really. Not after the first 8 hours.
When the commentators are sharing lineups, restaurants, lodging, and friends with the CT surfers in confined surf locations, the webcast will be void of objective commentating and disparaging remarks. Also, it’s easier to justify the broadcast inefficiencies when the audience does not have to pay a price to view.
https://youtu.be/e4iKfUKBWDk
I didn’t realise how much of a fan I was until he died.
I just meant for the general public who has no knowledge they can easily understand: clear winner.
for surfing , no idea.
Pottz wasn’t there, which made the commentary excellent.
Back in my day we didn’t have commentary
Back in my day we didn’t have orthodontists.
I’m not sure why the Wozzle feel that there must be non stop talking. Other live sports manage just fine without it: Football (Soccer), Tennis etc. Cricket, of course.
Would be great if they concentrated on the action, but didn’t blabber on endlessly. And I can’t remember watching another sport where basic stuff was explained all the time.
Great opinion. Commentary went to new levels of painfulness.
They all need to talk less and be more direct and factual about the action. But this is live TV folks, and we can’t have ‘dead air’, can we?
I used to hate Rosie but as she’s become more relaxed has improved with good pointed interviews with the surfers.
Great when Kelly is in the booth -all the others STFU; he says things that actually mean something, rather than waffle from….commentators. SSDD on other sports…heard the Xgames skating lately? It’s probably worse for the same reasons. We need more experienced surfers on commentary.
Absolutely – yes, such an easy fix, put the knocked out surfers in the booth. Works every time.
[Oh, and chose your seconds, for an insult to Rosie is a duelling offence. Pistols at dawn, sir!]
Rosie with Ronnie every time
You can cut the sexual tension with a knife!
Worlds too far gone to save . Its just going get shitter and shitter but this beats fucken spiders
Bro, I hope you get yourself some nice waves sometime soon ✌🏾
fully endorse the bootie ban.
the funniest/saddest thing about these commentators completely ignoring important action is that there’s SO MUCH downtime to fill. but even more than the on-air jokers you’ve got to look at the producers. in theory these people were hired for their skills, not because of their pro-surfing or madonna-romancing resumes.
one would think they’d be able to look at surfline and know when the lully day is going to happen and plan their coral stories and interviews to run on those days.
https://youtu.be/PNR5rgtT0v8
I am waking up every night .my ears in pain hearing in my nightmares the fucking Turpel’s unbearable pitch ,I dream on a local invasion of the line up on Dora’s heat..
The UFC just uploaded the Khabib vs Conor fight. Hilarious how the commentary was so pro-Conor when he was getting dominated. Joe Rogan, who usually talks Conor up, actually called it how was.
A classic case of the golden goose getting the push despite a slow death in front of the whole world…
It’s not a new idea but we really need an alternate feed…
Lewis Samuels, Shearer, Mason Ho, Vaughn Dead and Albee Layer for some salt. Crowdfund the thing, vote and enjoy. Live comments when things get slow.
Or we could just not crowdfund a bunch of clowns and spend our cash at a circus too hear talented clowns instead?
What brain power are u lacking to not just mute the commentary and play music instead?
Well that escalated quickly…
I would consider each person I mentioned as ‘talented’ and insightful whilst able to add their own flavour to the show.
Play music sans music to a surf comp? The Woozle ain’t Morning of the Earth…
Try some perspective.
For $8 a week you can give a child in the third world access to a limited education, limited food, limited healthcare and limited fresh drinking water.
Or we can crowdfund some well off white guys to talk about even more well off white guys surf because you aren’t happy with how the white guys talk about the white guys surfing at the moment?
Think about it….white guy
This is BeachGrit Ed…
Oh and btw, I’ve spent a few years working in developing countries with the type of children you’ve mentioned.
And I’m a man of colour.
Do you prefer Celine dion or Bieber??
Elevator music is suffice for 99% of heats
it makes no sense to me watching with music and commentary muted.
“keeping the fun in dysfunctional”
What has gears but no matter which gear is selected still whines?
Longtom and the rest the Aussie surf blog blogger’s
The Inertia called and want their patriotic/dadjoke/troll guy back…
generally speaking Ted, I think the Aussie surf blog scene is very supportive of pro surfing.
You see it differently?
It looks better than that classic Gath model. The one Tom Carol wore.
yup.
Mark Nicholas ruining the greatest moment in human history
https://www.youtube.com/wat…