Advertisement
Great White near surfer
"Is the new drone program just giving us a false sense of security whilst simultaneously spotting Sharks that have always been there and drumming up unnecessary fear?"

World’s Most Expensive Drone Program Under Fire After Surfer Narrowly escapes Great White Shark

“I was out there between 9-10am and didn’t see the drone make a pass once."

Yeah, well, they’re out there, the ol Great White shark. And the double-whammy of birds in the sky, inexpensive enough so half the city has ‘em, and the obvious surge in the population after thirty years of protection, has given pretty much everyone who surfs in Sydney the heebie jeebies about Great Whites, I think it’s fair to say. 

One month ago, you’ll remember, the NSW government announced drone surveillance across 70 beaches at a cost of $34 million, the most expensive shark spotting operation in the world, the whole program costing 120 mill.

The idea to fliy fleets of drones was a response to the mauling of Sydney mother Leah Stewart by a Great White off Coogee, the death of surfer Mercury Psillakis the previous September, a kid killed by a bull shark and a raft of other hits, encounters, incidents, whatever you wanna call em.

As I wrote one year ago, whenever I’m with the it’s-their-ocean crowd, I tell ’em: you gotta understand. This is only the beginning. In a generation nobody will want their kids paddling out into the blue when fatal attacks by Great Whites become a weekly sideshow and not, as in the case recently, every two or three months.

Advertisement

And as I wrote one month ago, the effect of the drone program will be to just how many sharks are kicking around and, hence, expect regular evacuations, beach closures etc.

And here we are.

Tom Bawdy writes: “Is the new drone program just giving us a false sense of security whilst simultaneously spotting Sharks that have always been there and drumming up unnecessary fear? I have never been more spooked surfing in Sydney.  Even nervous to sign the kids back up to nippers this year.”

Bodyboarder surfing Curl Curl, just north of Manly there, real close to the city, a joint supposedly patrolled by drones, gets checked by a 12-foot Great White.

Advertisement

“It got within a metre of me,” boog Luke Petersen told the Murdoch Press.

“I tried not to flap around too much and I told another guy I was surfing next to. He saw it also and we both were able to catch a little wave in. Then I just ran up the beach whistling out to all the other surfers to come in to shore.”

Petersen warned the other surfers about the Great White but says the shark alarm wasn’t sounded for another hour.

“The response from authorities was far too slow,” he said. “I was out there between 9-10am and didn’t see the drone make a pass once. I surf every day and to be honest I haven’t seen the drones patrolling all that much at Curl Curl.”

Advertisement

In contrast, a few headlands over at Avalon, a privately owned drone was used to warn a lone surfer about a nearby Great White, the shredder beaching himself to safety.

You like the drones?

I like ’em a hell of a lot and feel pretty comfortable when that lil red and yella tent is set up on the beach and the four-roter copter is doin’ the rounds.

Maybe they miss a few, maybe they don’t.

Advertisement

Either way, better than SharkBanz and apps displaying wearabouts of tagged sharks, I think safe to say.

0 0 votes
Article Rating

Chris Dixon and Frank: please email [email protected] from the address you'd like your BeachGrit login on.

Commented on Disqus? Log out, tap the Disqus button, and your old name and comments come back. The box is ours.

Join the discussion

Your comments are still here. Every one of them.

Twelve years of BeachGrit comments came across from Disqus. Connect and we will show you how many are yours. We get your username, nothing else.

Unclaimed
Handle
Comments
Posting since

Connect Disqus to reveal.

Subscribe
Notify of
15 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Sellme fitzgobbins

Time to become a pool surfer Derek, nice and safe at urban surf and no more whiney im so scared of shark stories
win win

The Bitchy Crab

But cold! More scared of cold than sharks. Surf China tank here I come!

channelbottom

Our club has been given an exy drone by Surfing NSW, and trained to use it. Pretty fricken cool. It’s got a speaker on it so you can talk to the surfers in the line up. No sharkies spotted yet. We’ve got a comp this weekend and who knows. Theory is they miss out our particular of the beach due to the nearby shelf, and cruise by further out before heading in along Stockton.

The Bitchy Crab

Bondi just got cleared cause of a big ol Gee Dub. Four-foot, real clean, empty.

KRIS

…surfed an insanely crowded point just last week, when the drone spied a shark and sounded the alarm. I didn’t realise until after the fact, thinking, ‘what the fuck is that noise?’ (akin to a distant, higher-pitched and heavily distorted car alarm)
Only culled half the crowd on the long stretch of point.
My point: maybe the Govt. needs to educate punters on the actual ‘alarm’ sound?
Alternatively, possibly use an 8bit high-pitch rendition of the Jaws theme!

Hippy

What do the drones do anyway except warn?

Does a siren protect you from the fire?

Barrelled

Call the Saffa’s and see if you pussies can borrow their orcas to deal with your cunty sharks.

Hippy

Humans consume tuna, are they worried about tuna populations?

Shrimp, crab can be farmed, but where is the environmentalism about every other edible fish? Sharks are just fish, Go Fish Australia

Don’t worry about their populations. There are heaps of shark in SA, Ca., Canada, etc. we can’t fish them to extinctinction. And if we do, then preserve for a short time to regenerate.

Would we accept bears mauling people on ski trails? Would humans accept crocs pulling golfers into the drink? Poisonous snakes occupying childrens play grounds?

Go Fish Australia

tim_nelsen

In shark adjacent news, Trump just allowed Wyoming to rear more grizzlies and by-pass federal culling laws. Make the bears great again! California, whose state flag posits such animals, had no comments~

https://uploads.disquscdn.c…

JSC

Drones do not stop sharks from biting people.

The end result of this massively expensive drone programme will be an extensive library of high-resolution 4k footage of people being torn apart by large sharks.

The Australian government could save all this money simply by licensing fishermen to catch 3 meter and larger sharks from near-shore waters – and sell the shark meat.

Removing large 3 meter plus sharks from the water solves the shark problem, full stop.

deeks

Shitting on your book doesn’t stop you biting

JSC

Book is selling well, thanks –

We are addressing the availability problem in Australia now, they should have copies soon, thanks for your patience!

JSC

Book is doing well, thanks!

Addressing the No Stock in Australia problem now, many people trying to buy a copy but it has been SOLD OUT on amazon.au for months and my sources confirm it is not available anywhere else in Australia, either.

Thanks for your patience, I’ll let you know as soon as copies are available!

Barrelled

The drones are nothing but a way to placate peoples anxiety about the sharks. To think a drone can be everywhere all the time is just fantasy land. And last time I checked, sharks are fish, they swim underwater and go really deep. Until someone develops a way to see through murky water from the air, you ain’t gonna see nothing but the few that venture to the surface and loll about.

Stick man

Something fishy about this story…


15
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x