Surf world bitterly polarized after surf loving dental student wonders if Utah or Florida is better choice for job

"I will be graduating from dental school. I want to go to Florida because I love to surf. My dad said go to Utah because they outlawed fluoride..."

Surfers who figured we reached peak polarization after Filipe Toledo’s second little wave world title* at Lower Trestles woke up with heads spinning, this morning, as a wild new divisive debate presented itself. The Durango Telegraph, which finds its home in Durango, Colorado and has been published since 2002, published a fiery query in its famed Ask Rachel column.

Dear Rachel,

I will be graduating from dental school. I want to go to Florida because I love to surf. My dad said go to Utah because they outlawed fluoride, and cavities are going to go up and there will be a lot of money to be had. He said old people in Florida have false teeth so no need for filings. I said Florida also outlawed fluoride. So what state do I choose?

– Tooth Brush

Surfers, near and far, immediately pitched into two camps. Those who were backing Utah celebrated the no fluoride mandate while also touting Zion Shores. Those who were backing Florida also celebrating no fluoride while also touting Typhoon Lagoon. The debate growing fiercer and more personal as it raged.

Thankfully, Rachel chimed in with her professional opinion, responding:

Dear Chomper Doctor,

I grew up with a dentist who loved the ocean. I mean LOVED it. The office was wallpapered in nautical motifs. The shelves had ships’ wheels and miniature lighthouses on them. He had boats (no thanks to me—I flossed!) and loved deep sea fishing. One problem: we were landlocked. Which is to say, in my mind, a dentist can afford to go surfing whenever he wants, no matter where he is. Go where your heart tells you, unless your dad is paying off your student debt.

– Rinse and swish, Rachel

Not helpful, tbh.

What are your thoughts?

0 0 votes
Article Rating

Commented on Disqus? Log out, tap the Disqus button, and your old name and comments come back. The box is ours.

Join the discussion

Your comments are still here. Every one of them.

Twelve years of BeachGrit comments came across from Disqus. Connect and we will show you how many are yours. We get your username, nothing else.

Unclaimed
Handle
Comments
Posting since

Connect Disqus to reveal.

Subscribe
Notify of
24 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Tom House

First time it occurred to me that banning fluoride is a BIG DENTIST move

Noncompetitor

Utah 💯

Spume

Go to Perú

SeverelyLtd

This comment merited an edit? How bad was it?

Surfador
Picard Madeoff

A truly intrepid reporter would invite this dentist in for an interview with live streamed Q&A on BG.

Keith Grace

More opportunities to stand sideways and “surf” in Utah for sure… but far more sugary alcoholic drinks consumed in Florida to build a dental practicce… do you want to be a millionaire dental icon in the community or ride waves and better yet, the greatest pow on earth?… the only answer is neither… get a 5-mil, an Epic or Ikon pass, a knowledge of Vermont’s back roads, a Subaru, and move to the U.S. coastal Northeast…

Sean Connery

Utah has a unique soda culture, driven in part by the Word of Wisdom, a health code of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, which discourages alcohol and hot caffeinated drinks like coffee and tea. This has led to a high consumption of soda, particularly “dirty sodas” which are sodas customized with syrups, creamers, and other flavorings. While not all Utahns are addicted to soda, the state’s soda consumption is a significant cultural and health issue.

Picard Madeoff

But is it as deadly as having more than one wife?

Keith Grace

had no clue… thanks for the info… last time I was in Utah in waist high pow I rec all the local kids crushing tall cans on tram at Snowbird… so much for absurd alcohol restrictions…

Picard Madeoff

So you end up with a subpar ski experience paired with cold water surfing.

Keith Grace

exactly… it’s our pathology over here…

Picard Madeoff

I have mad respect for NE skiers and surfers as you are tougher than those west of the Hudson or the Mississippi.

FL Skunk Ape

Pssst – they are doing the same here in FL

deeks

Dentists are worse than great whites. At least with a g.w. you don’t have to pay for every tooth!

DongWangVerga

Florida + Utah = flouridtah

Barnycle

Was this young lady featured on these pages? Miss England

https://www.gulte.com/trends/354977/miss-england-quits-miss-world-2025-felt-like-a-prostitute

should never allow surfers anywhere. They’re too cantankerous.

Piskian

Filings?
Irony?
Bruce or Andy?
So many questions.

Com Turren

Wait, did this guy really get a spray featuring the name of his dental practice? That’s actually a brilliant way to write off a surfboard as a business expense and I am unhappy that this did not occur to me until now.

https://uploads.disquscdn.c…

SeverelyLtd

Also, you forgot to get a DDS, did you not?

20 mule team

Delete this shit you goof.

Beef & Beer

My thoughts are of how impressive it is that you researched the subject enough to know both states (with equivalent poor surf) had no flouride in their water, and then went to the extent of tracking down a small online news service, opened an account under a false name, and whose agony aunt you then made enquiries to, while posing as a young dentist.
Bravo Chas, bravo…

Barnycle

This was my exact same salutation, even before reading your comment.

Although I suspect that he came across the ditty, and thankfully for us, decided to turn it into ………. something.

Chas Smith

Slow bow.


24
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x