Shane Dorian posits, "There are Indonesians and then there are foreigners. Living there does not make someone a local."
The Australian Lennix Smith is enjoying a viral online success after film of his altercation with an Italian surfer living in Indonesia lit up this past week.
Lennix, who is twenty-one, posted a video of the Italian ex-pat, identified as Edoardo Puddu, owner of Shardana West Sumbawa, makers of delicious European style pizzas and hosts par excellence at their homestay right there at Sumbawa’s Scar Reef, dropping on on him and subsequently becoming very animated.
I’m just going to show you a quick video of an altercation between me and a Spanish surfer who claims he’s lived in Indo for the last 25-plus years, and give you a rundown of what went down.
After dropping in on me, this guy paddles up to me as fast as he can, grabs my board, kicks it out from underneath me and screams: “I will fucking kill you. I will kill you. You just fucked up big time. I’ve been in Indo for a long time. Punch me, pussy. Punch me. Punch me. I dare you. I will kill you. I will smash your knee.”
And I’m like, “What the hell? Chill out, bro.”
And he’s like, “No, you fucked up. You snaked me. You snaked me, you fucking idiot. I will kill you. Why you laughing at me? Why you laughing?”
And I’m just like, “What the hell, bro? Chill out.”
Then for about ten minutes straight he kept telling me he was going to kill me, smash my knee and ruin my surf career, and that he didn’t give a fuck. Then he started doing this [throat-cutting gesture] at me, and I was like, what the hell even is that?
Honestly, I find it crazy that these guys come over here for five minutes, think they’re locals and start carrying on. They don’t realise they’re the ones ruining it for everyone. They come out with this crazy ego, the worst vibe ever, and they kill the vibe so hard. Surfing’s meant to be fun, and these guys are so aggressive they don’t even realise it.
So if you know who this is, tag him. It’ll be good for him to realise that people like him are the ones ruining it for everyone.
Eddy is tagged everywhere below the line with surf heavyweights Tom Carroll and Shane Dorian posting in favour of Lennix Smith.
Tom writes, “Nicely handled Lennix. He barely made it to his feet – however in his mind he was getting barrelled. Interesting times.”
And Shane Dorian, pointedly, “There are Indonesians and then there are foreigners, there is no in between. Living there does not make someone a local.”
Whose camp do you favour? Lenny or Eddy?
And, more importantly, can an ex-pat ever enjoy local status or is forever an outsider etc?
Commented on Disqus? Log out, tap the Disqus button, and your old name and comments come back. The box is ours.
Your comments are still here. Every one of them.
Twelve years of BeachGrit comments came across from Disqus. Connect and we will show you how many are yours. We get your username, nothing else.
Connect Disqus to reveal.
All these euros look the same
They don’t realise they’re the ones ruining it for everyone. They come out with this crazy ego, the worst vibe ever, and they kill the vibe so hard. Surfing’s meant to be fun, and these guys are so aggressive they don’t even realise it.
– that’s a solid description of almost every pro surfer
Look yourself in the mirror beagle manboy. That guy has been in indonesia for longer than you’ve been alive. Lives in front of the wave. Runs a hospitality business. He either had a full-on psychiatric episode, or you must have done some bad no-no?
Even if he was an actual local it’s still a kook move.
Yeah true i agree. As is complaining on social media about it. Lose/lose situation.
Don’t know any of them and wouldn’t want anywhere near. Enough assholes around as is.
Wasn’t it in the Ment’s and the dude lives at Scar?
No idea, but besides the point. Disagree with the whole ‘living here doesn’t make you a local’ schtick. At some point it does. Shane Dorian , jjf, job, none are polinesian yet they’re 1st generation Hawaiian or whatever.
And more importantly. If you had a restaurant and homestay business, abroad, mostly dependent of online reviews nowadays, would you act like that involuntarily? Towards a fucking millennial? He either had a psych episode or he had good reasons to flip.
Pysh episode for sure, totally unnecessary and totally not how to deal with a snake.
3 sides to every story…. aussies can be brutal as well. israelie the aggro’ist i ever encountered
Israelis always just put of national service and got a chip on their shoulder about it. Obnoxious assholes every single one of them.
Can we get ears on the chat Shane is queued to have with Fast Eddie? ho brah
Indo’s and Indon’ts…
Hey secret agent free/longy/tom tom, did you recognize McTavish under young Richmond’s feet in the vids? He has some fun towards the end of this one. Does more than alright where I am.
https://youtu.be/41pAEydP0_M
If Marama gets serious, no problem winning out there. If it’s real, anyone who likes the WA reefs around P Break area, and likes real grunt and looking at rocks. Jack Robbo. Same things with wind and tide though will apply. Epic can instantly become craggy, swirly, slop banging, collapsing, bark and tear shedding crap. Heat times will decide a lot.
Short memories. I saw JOB in his prime and Makua Rothman out there about 17/18 years ago. Deluxe days. Solo sessions the norm in that whole region. GL didn’t exist. JOB called it backdoor pipe 2.
https://www.surfertoday.com/surfing/jamie-obrien-scores-perfect-10-at-the-billabong-cloud-9-invitational-at-siargao-island
3 min 30 secs in.
not sure what that McT is, but could find out easily.
looks good.
you in GL or further north?
Gidday nowhere near GL. I’d like to watch the comp, and lots of my wife’s family are there, so it’s kind of easy, I’ve known the local boys there since they were little groms. Even they are over it, sure they have businesses etc, but it’s worse than going to Kuta, and they lament how fun their life used to be. There’s a huge, real divide on that whole island even in prominent families, about turning the place back into a semblance of what it was, whilst keeping the good things about ‘progress’. About returning to a life of fishing, farming, etc, etc, getting their land and Cultures back. It will be a behind the scenes shitfight, like the whole sleazy ziff money churner, all the cunning, sleazy, jockying ‘foreigners’, preening and grovelling to the ruthless crocodiles. Positioning for a quid. And like the Bali/Java thing, the lure of gold enticing all and sundry from the, ‘big smoke’. From the top of the chain, to the depths of hell. The surfees will get to see a paraded version that the local people, the people who will be actually financing the view, can only dream of. Like electricity, and water. And even a glimpse of the spectacle. Then when its over…
I know young Richmond well, he’s from over your way, so I know the boards.
Someone was saying Gabby will dominate. I disagreed for the reason you post above. Looks like the box kind of setup, really not a good wave as a goofy if you’re against a top natural footer. Doubt you can do a backside air on your first turn, can’t get as deep on your backside when it pitches like that, and end section doesn’t look right for a big backside turn at the finish.
Yep, if it’s real, the box description is a good one. Easy to get seriously shredded, crunched and mangled. I’ve seen some horrific wounds, especially on those underestimating it.
But like even Tahiti, if its below that line, its a playground, especially with that viewing, entry platform, for learners and gronks, and their cameras and stuff.
But did young Lennix snake? Sure, a gross overreaction, but you would be pissed too if you lived and surfed somewhere for 25 years and some hothoused aussie pro kid comes and snakes you.
Also, is he Italian or Spanish? I met an Italian in indo recently that was the worst, paddling all over the lineup, paddling for every wave, completely oblivious that he was the only one doing it. Is this just how Italians roll?
Yes, young, innocent until… lennix, ‘found’ himself, and perhaps his ‘sponnos’ or dreams, somehow in poll position. Somehow, perhaps a stocky, chitty chat, ozzy smiley, stupe’ n craggo, swillnutty, ‘gggggiiidddaaayyy mmmmmmaaaaaayyyytttteee’, enny wun seen pete… float by… or the likes. That, in the desert anyway, in the real world, quickly ended in tears.
?
A Welcome Back Camper story:
I’d been living in Oz for a couple of years and sailing the Pacific. returned home, and the first morning the waves looked fun out front of the house, Welcome back.
I paddle out, sit in my favorite spot which is a bit deep, spin and go on my first wave and a whitehead burns me. I don’t say anything, but get back out through the channel and back to my lineup position.
I chill for a bit enjoying being home, then go another. Whitehead thinking he’s just burning another blow-in (no offense to Blowin) whitehead…burns me again. Rinse, repeat. So next time I paddle over more toward the shoulder and wait for Whitehead to take off…he does and I stuff him. I paddle out the back and he’s sitting there glaring at me and says: “what Brah, you burn me…who you?”…
I chuckle, which annoys him and he says “Brah…you don’t live here, you don’t surf here!” so I says: “why, where you from?”
He says: “Brah, I live Logs,..been surfing here 12 years. Where you from?”
I say: “here”
He says: “Never seen you, Brah. Go back to Cali, you kook”
I says: “I lived here for 40 years and never seen you”
He says: “Yeah right Brah, nevah seen you, where you live?”
so I just point at my house on the beach…
at this moment an old friend of mine, a well known heavy who has since passed, paddles over, smiles, hugs me and says: “Ho Camper, when’d you get back? Welcome home”
Whitehead looks at me, looks at heavy, who is now staring at him, and I say: “may be time for you to paddle in”. He did…and every time I saw him after that, he never burned me again.
Surfing’s meant to be fun
Indo has become a dog show from North Sumatra to Rote. With over crowding leading to cuntish behaviour by people from everywhere but more recently Euro surfers from Spain and France are often the worst. The death knell however is largely due to the explosion of Indonesian surfers who I guess correctly feel they can have any wave they want.
the Indos are cool- talk to ’em and don’t hassle and you’ll get plenty.
the euro kooks have got no fucking idea.
Not going back. Last trip was to the Ments in July and I’ve been going regularly to various parts since the early nineties. I’ve seen a steady decline from epic to ridiculous with the explosion of Ex-pats/homestays/charters/land camps bringing hordes of travellers to previously out of the way places. Bali of course has been a no go for years already. These factors coupled with the growth of local surfers has tipped the scale down to the shit show level. While the zone undoubtably has the best waves on the planet, Durban and its north and south coasts can get as good with plenty of places within easy striking distance that are always uncrowded. This makes it an easy decision for me to avoid any further disappointment at the disappeared Indo dream.
Gabby Medina is going to break hearts with his upcoming win at Cloud 9
Get ready for a rampage whereby he redefines backhand reef tube riding and end section blasts over barely submerged coral in the way JJF rewrote the manual on open faced carves at Margs right.
Otherwise talented surfers going to get rekt.
Don’t think so, not on that wave. But happy to be proven wrong.
agree, probably the worst wave imaginable for Gabe.
OH Lordy….get ready to be educated. He’s the best surfer in the world. The tip of the spear for the improvement of performance surfing. This piddling, dinky right will be like chopsticks to Mozart. He’ll be seeing opportunities that we can’t imagine
Gabby is fucking rad, I love watching him surf and he’s got a bit of cunt about him, like that time he dropped in on slater at backdoor. That was epic.
I saw him win his first ever comp in France in about 2011. Knew he was going to be a star.
I just don’t think he’ll be able to get deeper than the top natural footers on a wave like that.
Nah Griff will be unstoppable at pumping cloud 9 me thinks. Robbo might finally find some form too.
Cloud 9 forecast –
Swell
These are my group-velocity estimates, not wave-model output. Times are local (UTC+8) and ±12 hours.
“That move of felching helps the swell build ” you dirty man John you dirty dirty mang
what time does the Kelvin wave arrive?
This is one of the most hilarious things I’ve seen, even better than some of the desert squwarkdowns. And some of them were all time epic.
A french guy and his lady paddled out and fuck knows why, the guy, a total gronk, started hassling the local boys. He did the same as the article, full screaming bunter thing, at a local boy, who he cut off and collided with as they paddled, both going over the falls. Then, when they finally both got back to the peak, the gronk threatened to, ‘seriously fuck him up’, and pointed to the beach and took off, with his lady.
I was joking with the local boy, who I knew was no slouch, and had had a wild upbringing, in the city, in heavy, heavy, heavy, life and death, life’s cheap, dog eat dog surroundings, perhaps an even gnarlier childhood than JJF’s even. And, he was supposed to officially be in good behavior mode. He wanted a few waves in peace, before doing the paddle, so took his time, and headed in.
The boys said the french guy was strutting, doing the full shadow boxing, jabbing, sparring, weaving, dodging, Pacquiao, speed kills/Volk 2 knees and kicks, exhibition combo. A friend had his camera, and the boys said when boy got in, he ignored the gronk, who as boy was leaving the water and walking up the beach, was giving him the full french foreign legion, let’s go squwarkup, finally screaming, ‘sacre’ bleu… eye em eh sweillnuet… ewe blaireau!!!’ And then the gronk made his move.
The end result was one of the best, welcome to the real world, surfeein’ vids ever!!! Only gronk’s girlfriend and boys good behavior status, plus he already knew it would be hilarious, so was being playfull, saved the pink panther. Sort of. Action replays, and eventually, even his lady was laughing at him. Even boy’s only comment, cruisy, to the lady, was epic. ‘You can’t say fuck me’.
If I’ve said it once I’ve said it a thousand times, here and elsewhere over the years.
Bloody bullfighting wankers the lot of ’em.
Spanish, Italians, Israelis, any and all Mediterranean types, Mexicans, Central and South Americans.
Arseholes all.
Basically any countries which have bullfighting and/or are near countries which have bullfighting are total pricks in the water.
They should NEVER have been introduced to the sport of Polynesian kings.
Them and the East Europeans and Ruskies etc.
Ban them all…
Word up. Lol.
an equal opportunity hater. Lots to go around the world.
Ticos are alright to surf with, as long as it’s not crowded and they’re not an aspiring pro ( despite their love of bullfighting). They’re a chill people, and they’ve learned to surf alongside the yanks.
More likely a side-effect of cultures that embrace machismo
Glad i’m on the good side of gibraltar! Fuck those Mediterraneans lol
Where are you based?
today my username can be the opposite of yours. Surfingtoday. Took the day off. Spent 5 hours driving, round trip, and got skunked both places that I paddled out. The swell I was hoping for never really materialised, although I got it on the wrong tide.
Portugal. Good for you. Spent the day not surfing, commenting on BG and checking supertubos on the local surfcams, it was pumping. Its on a funny angle where you see the lineup sideways.
https://beachcam.meo.pt/livecams/peniche-supertubos/
You’re still officially on the banned list being next door to Spain…
I miss Hippy.
Probably they were paddling around him, but what is the alternative? Sit down on the inside and wait for this guy to barrel dodge before they allowed to paddle to the actual takeoff spot?
Knead the dough.
The incident took place in the Mentawais, where no one really hold local status. This guy has a camp in West Sumbawa and now thinks his “local” status applies across the whole archipelo. Both were probably somewhat at fault here.
Gotta say after just spending the last month in Indo, after me the worst paddle past everyone to the inside were the Sustralians.
That with being a semi pro, just maybe young Lennix is a dog in the line up?
Kiwis always want to find Aussies at fault. Default fucken setting
cuzzy bros don’t mind paddling up to the top either.
Aussies do moan more than us. But we’re over there living the dream I guess.
*Australians. Fuck this platform and the no edit.
I thought “Sustralian” was a purposeful portmanteau of suss and Australian – fit the vibe of your post even
Gonna agree. Many Aussie, even the couple of guys I surf with sometimes, chat a lot about etiquette and respect and have disdain for perceived bad behavior in the lineup, but then they put on a wetsuit and paddle and are cutthroat aggressive and rule breaking. There’s dissonance there for sure.
It is known that many aussies can see the speck in your eye but ignore the log in their own. This chap in the Middle East once wrote about it.
The Beagle may laugh alot, but he’s grown up in the boxing garage with the rest of the RillaPak !
So is he Italian or Spanish?
Aussies wouldn’t know the difference
no need
We figured it out pretty quick in WW2.
Everyone thinks Hitler was a German so I suppose it happens eh
A Spanish gal told me Italian is just bad Spanish – and an Italian gal told me Spanish is just bad Italian.
Portuguese is just Spanish being spoken by a drunk Frenchman. Guaranteed to get all three nationalities riled.
Derek, I have another request. When clicking on a link in the comments, please have it open in a new window. That’s how most sites work. I forget to use the back arrow and end up having to go back into the article from scratch. It should be an easy fix – probably one box to check.
Yeah, I’ll let the developer know.
How about reverting back to the old system ?
Xox