Instant dismissal for terrible judging! Yes or no?
Whatever you wanna think about the UFC’s frontman Dana White and the nature of blood sport with its ring girls and that ballbearing wiggle of their honey dews between rounds, he’s a straight-shooter.
And, so, yesterday, after one of his three judges made an error so egregious it couldn’t be ignored, the call came in and the judge was sacked mid-card, a decision MMA fans hailed as “landmark.”
A couple of typical responses on Facebook.
This is incredible and such a landmark moment for holding these terrible judges responsible for their actions. I have been saying for years that judges with these kind of atrocious scorecards should be escorted out of the building and it finally happened The company needs to keep this up. That is one of the worst score cards in MMA history.
MMA will now be absolutely changed. I felt relieved seeing him relieved of his duties. Abysmal judging.
Howie Booth was one of three judges at UFC305 hitting the score cards for the heavyweight bout between Australian Tai “Bam Bam” Tuivasa and Surinamese fighter Jairzinho Rozenstruik.
Jairzinho Rozenstruik beat hell out of Bam Bam for three rounds but when it came down to read the score cards, turned out ol Howie gave every round to Bam Bam. The other two judges were the mirror opposite, all three rounds to Rozenstruik, making it a split-decision.
Wild judging decisions have long been a hallmark of the UFC, less so in WSL events although it does happen.
And, so, to bite off the particular cancer tough decisions gotta be made. Mid-card, zero minutes notice, judge sacked.
Which leads to surfing, the WSL and Finals Day which runs real soon, September six through fourteen, whenever waves are good or good-ish, this is Southern California after all.
Should judges be ripped out of their seats mid-event if they’re not punching the right buttons, and not just ’cause they had a photo taken with a competitor?
Elo was disappeared overnight, could not the same levers be pulled?
And what would that mean for the Brazilian surf fan army? Neutralised or emboldened?